6533b7d4fe1ef96bd1261ddb
RESEARCH PRODUCT
Mapping geographical inequalities in childhood diarrhoeal morbidity and mortality in low-income and middle-income countries, 2000-17: analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017
Manisha DubeyFatemeh RajatiMehran Shams-beyranvandAmir KhaterReza ShirkoohiSegun Emmanuel IbitoyeDavid C. SchwebelMilena IlicKebede Embaye GezaeAli Akbar FazaeliRonny WestermanTaye Abuhay ZewaleRavi MehrotraSezer KisaJunaid KhanJost B. JonasDian KusumaMarcel AusloosGetnet GedefawHamed ZandianEdward J MillsAparna LalAtalay Goshu MulunehLeeberk Raja InbarajEdgar Denova-gutiérrezJacqueline Elizabeth Alcalde RabanalYousef VeisaniSharath Burugina NagarajaChristopher TroegerIsmael R. Campos-nonatoKidane Tadesse GebremariamMaysaa El Sayed ZakiOliver J. BradyDavid Laith RawafTamer H. FaragSimin MouodiHafiz Ansar Rasul SuleriaSaleh Salehi ZahabiSoumyadeep BhaumikSamad AzariGetinet AyanoFaris LamiRaaj Kishore BiswasMaryam AdabiAlaa BadawiSaravanan MuthupandianAmir HasanzadehMartin Amogre AyanoreMaziar Moradi-lakehMohamad-hani TemsahKavumpurathu Raman ThankappanBineyam TayeNader Jafari BalalamiHamid Yimam HassenKarzan Abdulmuhsin MohammadPaul H. LeeEmerito Jose A. FaraonKewal KrishanMuhammad AliEhsan SadeghiRichard C. FranklinDara K. MohammadNaznin HossainLal B. RawalAlyssa N. SbarraBehnam HeidariDietrich RothenbacherHagos Tasew AtalayEric L. DingNoushin MohammadifardNihal ThomasMan Mohan MehndirattaSanghamitra PatiAddisu MeleseNiranjan KissoonFarzad ManafiCarl Abelardo T. AntonioMorteza Abdullatif KhafaieMeysam BehzadifarMohammad Reza SobhiyehFrank B. OseiKoku Sisay TamiratYahya SalimiPranab ChatterjeeGebreamlak Gebremedhn GebremeskelOlatunji O. AdetokunbohBenjamin K. MayalaBhaskaran UnnikrishnanZahid A ButtOlufemi AjumobiFiseha Wadilo WadaShafiu MohammedCharles Shey Shey WiysongeFélix CarvalhoMasresha Tessema AnegagoYun Jin KimAi-min WuKetema Bizuwork GebremedhinPaulina A. LindstedtAna-laura MandaAziz EftekhariRakhi DandonaMehdi FazlzadehNicole Davis WeaverMuluken Bekele SorrieMarwa Rashad SalemKassawmar Angaw BogaleDongyu ZhangSaeed SafariVivekanand JhaKeivan AhmadiTurki AlanziAmir JalaliHamidreza HaririanChukwudi A NnajiKebadnew Mulatu MihretieLucas Guimarães AbreuGessessew Bugssa HailuSurendra KarkiKirsten E. WiensBoikhutso TlouSoraya SiabaniMuluken Azage YenesewAsnakew Achaw AyeleAyalew Jejaw ZelekeOsayomwanbo OsarenotorSusanna DunachieMarcos Roberto Tovani-paloneDaniel Bekele KetemaTissa WijeratneDessalegn Ajema BerbadaAndré KarchEbrahim BabaeeAkram PourshamsSeyyed Meysam MousaviBal Govind ChauhanGiuseppe RemuzziVera Marisa CostaMehdi YaseriTahereh PashaeiBenn SartoriusHelen Derara DiroAnelisa JacaMostafa HosseiniNikolay Ivanovich BrikoFranz CastroCuong Tat NguyenChalachew Genet AkalNatalie Maria CormierGhulam MustafaSonia LewyckaAchala Upendra JayatillekeDavid L. SmithIbrahim A KhalilGenet Melak AlameneGeorge C PattonAndem EffiongGebrekiros Gebremichael MelesCollins ChansaTsegaye Lolaso LenjeboVan C. LansinghChabila C MapomaOlayinka Stephen IlesanmiAso Mohammad DarweshAubrey J. LevineMiliva MozafforTill BärnighausenAli RostamiAndré FaroRushdia AhmedColm McalindenDuduzile NdwandweNeeraj BediIrfan UllahWinfried MärzRajeev GuptaMasood Ali ShaikhCatalina Liliana AndreiAli Kazemi KaryaniShaimaa I. El-jaafaryAbbas MosapourJavad NazariObinna OnwujekweNarinder Pal SinghDabere NigatuTanuj KanchanJagdish KhubchandaniAklilu EndalamfawHajer ElkoutMichelle L. BellBeyene Meressa AdhenaEvanson Z. SambalaNelson Alvis-guzmanNefsu AwokeMohammad Ali SahraianMuki SheyChristiane DolecekKedir Hussein AbegazSyed Ather HussainBirhan Tamene AlemnewArash EtemadiAnwar E. AhmedVinay NangiaSachin R AtreRoghiyeh FaridniaRobert C. ReinerRajat Das GuptaAniruddha DeshpandeSanjay ZodpeyBirhanu GetaAmaha KahsayMuktar Beshir AhmedKiana RamezanzadehJacek Jerzy JozwiakChi Linh HoangBahram ArmoonManfred AccrombessiChristopher J L MurrayEbrahim M YimerRashmi GuptaAhmed Omar BaliDadi MaramiArash Tehrani-banihashemiGetnet MengistuGovinda Prasad DhunganaFereshteh AnsariDina Nur Anggraini NingrumMu'awiyyah Babale SufiyanHarish Chander GugnaniAli S. AkandaSatar RezaeiWondimeneh Shibabaw ShiferawIrina FilipMohammad FareedHagos Degefa HidruMorteza ShamsizadehMojtaba Hoseini-ghahfarokhiYared A Asmare AynalemGelin XuZubair KabirKhalid A AltirkawiBeatriz Paulina Ayala QuintanillaKenean Getaneh TlayeDevasahayam J. ChristopherMalede Mequanent SisayYibeltal Alemu BekeleMika ShigematsuBryan L. SykesQuique BassatJemal Abdu MohammedSeyed Mostafa MirMoslem SoofiNuruzzaman KhanEnsiyeh JenabiSeyed-mohammad FereshtehnejadAlireza EsteghamatiParamjit GillNathaniel J HenryMeghnath DhimalHosein ShabaninejadTrang Huyen NguyenAmjad Mohamadi-bolbanabadEugenio TrainiMohammad ZamaniArianna Maever L. AmitMehran AlijanzadehFlorian FischerRafael Moreira ClaroPushpendra KumarShai LinnLucas EarlHaileab Fekadu WoldeGetenet DessieDoris V.v. Ortega-altamiranoJohn S. JiMoritz U. G. KraemerSaeed AminiZiad A. MemishAisha ElsharkawyKen Lee ChinMustafa Z. YounisDaniel DiazHebat Allah Salah A. YousofSeifadin Ahmed ShalloTomohide YamadaAdrian PanaSalman RawafAmir Almasi-hashianiPlaton D. LopukhovAlireza RafieiDragos Virgil DavitoiuHossein PoustchiAyele Geleto BaliFrancesco Saverio ViolanteLeonardo RoeverGiovanni DamianiMaha El TantawiNuworza KugbeyHadi PourjafarMichael R.m. AbrigoDinh-toi ChuFarkhonde SalehiPhetole Walter MahashaFarnam MohebiSathish ThirunavukkarasuDharmesh Kumar LalSenbagam DuraisamyDemelash Woldeyohannes HandisoEleonora DubljaninTakeshi FukumotoBiruck Desalegn YirsawFakher RahimJasvinder A. SinghJai K DasSavita LasradoAna Isabel RibeiroSantosh VarugheseAdnan KisaLaurie B. MarczakAmira ShaheenPeter Njenga KeiyoroNader JahanmehrYuming GuoArash ZiapourAlex YeshanehNinuk HariyaniSeyed Sina Naghibi IrvaniSameer Vali GopalaniJoel M. FrancisAsmamaw DemisAhamarshan Jayaraman NagarajanPraveen HoogarNicola Luigi BragazziYunquan ZhangYousef MohammadIman El SayedVafa Rahimi-movagharAnbissa Muleta SenbetaSubramanian SenthilkumaranMarzieh NojomiTewodros Eshete WondeSameh MagdeldinAnton SokhanNauman KhalidNima Hafezi-nejadBen LaceyLuca RonfaniJames AlbrightSenthilkumar BalakrishnanEjaz Ahmad KhanKhanh Bao TranGuoqing HuYousef KhaderParvaneh MirabiBoris BikbovFeleke Mekonnen DemekeAssefa DesalewYasir WaheedBerhe Etsay TesfayJulio Cesar Campuzano RinconErnoiz AntriyandartiBrian J. HallJames A Platts-millsGbenga A. KayodeJan-walter De NeveMaria Jesus Rios-blancasNavid ManafiRavi Prakash JhaYilma Chisha Dea GeramoHamideh SalimzadehFisaha Haile TesfayAbdullah Al MamunAli BijaniHedley QuintanaShanshan LiKebreab PaulosJoan B. SorianoVictor AdekanmbiOladimeji AdebayoDavid Teye DokuBrijesh SathianBakhtiar PirooziMohammadbagher ShamsiNetsanet FentahunShymaa EnanyAyman GradaSalvatore RubinoKenji ShibuyaNorberto PericoSergio I. PradaAndrea FarioliGebremicheal Gebreslassie KasahunMohsen AfaridehMaciej BanachAndrey Nikolaevich BrikoMohsen Asadi-lariRakesh LodhaDavid M. PigottBárbara Niegia Garcia De GoulartHadi HassankhaniDaniel Adane EndalewSiamak SabourYoshan MoodleyPreeti DhillonDilaram AcharyaDilaram AcharyaAnas M. SaadIbrahim Abdelmageed GinawiTheo VosTuomo J. MeretojaIreneous N. SoyiriHasan YusefzadehMohammad RabieeAjay PatleRahman ShiriGirmay Teklay WeldesamuelSivan Yegnanarayana Iyer SaraswathyMekdes Tigistu YilmaDavide GuidoChuanhua YuAbdallah M. SamyAli Talha KhalilAshish AwasthiPascual R. ValdezNelson G.m. GomesNejimu Biza ZeproTaweewat WiangkhamAnthony MasakaAfsaneh ArzaniAyesha HumayunMichael Tamene HaileHuyen Phuc DoKrittika BhattacharyyaMaryam KhayamzadehSeth Christopher Yaw AppiahMehdi AhmadiFarah DaoudQuynhanh P NguyenSuleman AtiqueSheikh Mohammed Shariful IslamIndang TrihandiniMario PoljakBartosz MiazgowskiHuda BasaleemRafael Alves GuimaresMina AnjomshoaPeng JiaYafeng WangErkin M. MirrakhimovSeyed Hossein Yahyazadeh JabbariItamar S. SantosAlireza KhatonyDesalegn Tadese MengistuSamath D DharmaratneS. Mohammad SajadiFrancisco Rogerlândio Martins-meloShankar M BakkannavarKonrad PesudovsTina BeyranvandLiliana PreotescuLeticia Avila-burgosEnrico RubagottiAmira Hamed DarwishMahdi SafdarianAli YadollahpourVijay Kumar ChattuMoses K. MuriithiAzmeraw T. AmareAzmeraw T. AmareSi SiJoshua LongbottomSomayeh BohlouliKhaled KhatabMasoud BehzadifarAnusha Ganapati BhatG Anil KumarMargaret KosekMona M. KhaterReta Tsegaye GayesaGhobad MoradiSrinivas GoliRuth W KimokotiJalal ArablooKimberly B. JohnsonAndrew T OlagunjuMowafa HousehIn-hwan OhArya Haj-mirzaianDesta Haftu HayelomJae Il ShinAhmed AbdelalimCatherine A. WelganVeincent Christian Filipino PepitoAndre Rodrigues DuraesYuan-pang WangRosario CárdenasMohammad KhazaeiSebastian VollmerXiu-ju ZhaoMihajlo JakovljevicDegu AbateAli S. ShalashDavide RasellaMelese Abate RetaHedayat AbbastabarManu Raj MathurAliasghar Ahmad KiadaliriRitesh G. MenezesMolly K. Miller-petrieBeriwan Abdulqadir AliAhmed I. HasaballahJoseph FrostadEirini SkiadaresiAleksandra BaracSimon I. HayDeborah Carvalho MaltaBrigette F. BlackerCarlo La VecchiaEduarda FernandesChandrashekhar T SreeramareddyZewdie Aderaw AlemuFoad Abd-allahElias Merdassa RoroAgus SudaryantoFariba GhassemiBehzad Karami MatinMohsen NaghaviMaarten J. PostmaChhabi Lal RanabhatMaheswar SatpathyMahesh P ACarlos Miguel Rios GonzálezPallab K. MaulikAmir KasaeianAli H. MokdadAlemayehu Toma MenaTamirat Tesfaye DasaAbdur Razzaque SarkerAndre M. N. RenzahoMuhammad Aziz RahmanAli KabirJosephine W. NgunjiriAberash Abay TassewKala M. MehtaIonut NegoiHosni SalemHesham M. Al-mekhlafiSharareh EskandariehRufus A. AdedoyinSaleem M RanaEngida YismaSahel Valadan TahbazHossein FarzamKrishna K. AryalLalit DandonaMasoud MoradiJuan SanabriaGebre Teklemariam DemozNaser Mohammad Gholi MezerjiShirin DjalaliniaSuraj BhattaraiAmmas Siraj MohammedClaudiu HerteliuDawit Zewdu WondafrashMohsen BayatiArvin Haj-mirzaianGulfaraz KhanMostafa LeiliNasir SalamEhsan KhodamoradiJean Jacques NoubiapVahid AlipourMohammad Ali MansourniaRajesh SagarJagadish Rao PadubidriManasi KumarMehdi SharifFatemeh HeydarpourNavid RabieeGvs MurthyHamed KalaniMayowa O. OwolabiClaudio Alberto DavilaOluchi OkpalaShivakumar K.m. KondlahalliMathew M. BaumannBereket Duko AdemaLorenzo MonastaPaul S. F. YipMohammad Hossein KhosraviRizwan Suliankatchi AbdulkaderIbrahim AbdollahpourDhirendra N SinhaFarid NajafiKebede DeribePaula MoragaMehedi HasanMohammad Moradi-jooMelkamu Merid MengeshaTemesgen Yihunie AkaluVishnu RenjithSyed Mohamed AljunidZemenu Tadesse TessemaAmir RadfarNuno TaveiraMasoud ForoutanDemelash Abewa EleminehChinwe Juliana IwuKamarul Imran MusaGetaneh Alemu AbebeFarshad PourmalekOlatunde AremuMohammad Reza SalahshoorDerrick A BennettAhmad DaryaniAlebachew Fasil AshagreApurba ShilNarayan Bahadur MahotraNelson J. Alvis-zakzukLauren E. SchaefferAlexandre C. PereiraMehdi NaderiMehdi HosseinzadehRovshan KhalilovAi KoyanagiSalman KhazaeiJennifer RickardAli AlmasiAli AlmasiSandra B. MunroCarlos Zambrana-torrelioNaohiro YonemotoAhmad Ghashghaeesubject
Low income countriesmedicine.medical_treatment030204 cardiovascular system & hematologyGlobal HealthTHERAPYGlobal Burden of Disease0302 clinical medicinePrevalenceGlobal healthMedicineWATER030212 general & internal medicineChildren11 Medical and Health SciencesIncidenceMortality rateIncidence (epidemiology)1. No povertyGeneral Medicine3142 Public health care science environmental and occupational healthDiarrhoea3. Good healthChild PreschoolMiddle income countriesA990 Medicine and Dentistry not elsewhere classifiedTERRITORIESLife Sciences & BiomedicineInfantsDiarrheaAFRICAmedicine.medical_specialtyChildhood deathsRJsanitationDeveloping countryChildhood diarrhoeal morbidityITC-HYBRID03 medical and health sciencesMedicine General & InternalGeneral & Internal MedicineEnvironmental healthSYSTEMATIC ANALYSISLife ScienceHumansHealthcare DisparitiesOral rehydration therapyRisk factorhand washingDeveloping CountriesDisease burdenGlobal NutritionWereldvoedingScience & TechnologySEX-SPECIFIC MORTALITYbusiness.industryCHOLERAPublic healthBayes Theoremdiarrheal diseaseLocal Burden of Disease Diarrhoea CollaboratorsITC-ISI-JOURNAL-ARTICLENAHuman medicineDiarreabusinessdescription
Background: Across low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs), one in ten deaths in children younger than 5 years is attributable to diarrhoea. The substantial between-country variation in both diarrhoea incidence and mortality is attributable to interventions that protect children, prevent infection, and treat disease. Identifying subnational regions with the highest burden and mapping associated risk factors can aid in reducing preventable childhood diarrhoea. Methods: We used Bayesian model-based geostatistics and a geolocated dataset comprising 15 072 746 children younger than 5 years from 466 surveys in 94 LMICs, in combination with findings of the Global Burden of Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors Study (GBD) 2017, to estimate posterior distributions of diarrhoea prevalence, incidence, and mortality from 2000 to 2017. From these data, we estimated the burden of diarrhoea at varying subnational levels (termed units) by spatially aggregating draws, and we investigated the drivers of subnational patterns by creating aggregated risk factor estimates. Findings: The greatest declines in diarrhoeal mortality were seen in south and southeast Asia and South America, where 54·0% (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 38·1-65·8), 17·4% (7·7-28·4), and 59·5% (34·2-86·9) of units, respectively, recorded decreases in deaths from diarrhoea greater than 10%. Although children in much of Africa remain at high risk of death due to diarrhoea, regions with the most deaths were outside Africa, with the highest mortality units located in Pakistan. Indonesia showed the greatest within-country geographical inequality; some regions had mortality rates nearly four times the average country rate. Reductions in mortality were correlated to improvements in water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) or reductions in child growth failure (CGF). Similarly, most high-risk areas had poor WASH, high CGF, or low oral rehydration therapy coverage. Interpretation: By co-analysing geospatial trends in diarrhoeal burden and its key risk factors, we could assess candidate drivers of subnational death reduction. Further, by doing a counterfactual analysis of the remaining disease burden using key risk factors, we identified potential intervention strategies for vulnerable populations. In view of the demands for limited resources in LMICs, accurately quantifying the burden of diarrhoea and its drivers is important for precision public health. This work was primarily supported by a grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (OPP1132415). S Aljunid reports additional funding from the International Centre for Casemix and Clinical Coding, Faculty of Medicine, National University of Malaysia and Department of Health Policy and Management, Faculty of Public Health, Kuwait University for the approval and support to participate in this research project outside of the study. A Awasthi is supported by the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India, New Delhi, through the INSPIRE Faculty Program outside of the study. A Badawi reports additional funding from the Public Health Agency of Canada outside of the study. A Barac reports additional funding from the Project of Ministry of Education, Science and Technology of the Republic of Serbia (no III45005) outside of the study. T Bärnighausen reports additional funding by the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation through the Alexander von Humboldt Professor award, funded by the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research outside of the study. F Carvalho and E Fernandez report additional funding from the Portuguese national funds (UID/MULTI/04378/2019 and UID/QUI/50006/2019) outside of the study. V M Costa reports additional funding from Fundação da Ciência e Tecnologia (FCT) for her grant (SFRH/BPD/110001/2015), which was funded by national funds through FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, IP, under the Norma Transitória – DL57/2016/CP1334/CT0006 outside of the study. J De Neve reports additional funding from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation outside of the study. K Deribe reports additional funding from the Wellcome Trust (grant number 201900) as part of his International Intermediate Fellowship outside of the study. D Endalew and M Moradi report additional funding from Wolkite University. M Ausloos, C Herteliu, and A Pana report additional funding from the Romanian National Authority for Scientific Research and Innovation, CNDS-UEFISCDI (project number PN-III-P4-ID-PCCF-2016-0084) outside of the study. C Herteliu reports additional funding from the European Fund for Regional Development through Operational Program for Competitiveness (Project ID P_40_382) and the European Fund for Regional Development, through InterReg Romania-Hungary (project code EMS ROHU 217) outside of the study. P Hoogar reports additional funding from the Centre for Holistic Development and Research (CHDR), Kalaghatagi and The Department of Studies in Anthropology, Karnatak University, D S Islam reports additional funding from the National Heart Foundation of Australia and the Institute for Physical Activity and Nutrition, Deakin University outside of the study. A Khatony reports additional funding from the Clinical Research Development Center of Imam Reza Hospital in Kermanshah outside of the study. J Khubchandani reports additional funding from Merck Research Laboratories outside of the study. K Krishan reports additional funding from the UGC Center of Advanced Study (CAS II) awarded to the Department of Anthropology, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India outside of the study. M Kumar reports additional funding from the Fogarty Foundation/NIH through a K43 award (TW010716-01A1) outside of the study. B Lacey reports additional funding from the National Institute for Health Research Oxford Biomedical Research Centre and the British Heart Foundation Centre of Research Excellence (Oxford, UK) outside of the study. A M Samy reports additional funding from the Egyptian Fulbright Mission Program (EFMP) outside of the study. S Seyedmousavi reports additional funding from the Intramural Program of National Institute of Health Clinical Center, Bethesda, MD, USA outside of the study. M Shey reports additional funding from the Wellcome Trust Kenji Shibuya reports additional funding from Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare and Japan's Ministry of Education, Culture, Sport, Science and Technology outside of the study. M Sobhiyeh reports additional funding from the Clinical Research Development Center of Imam Reza Hospital, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences outside of the study. J Soriano reports additional funding from Centro de Investigación en Red de Enfermedades Respiratorias (CIBERES), Instituto de Salud Carlos III (ISCIII), Madrid, Spain outside of the study. N Taveira reports additional funding from the LIFE study (RIA2016MC-1615) of the European and Developing Countries Clinical Trials Partnership (EDCTP) program supported by the European Union outside of the study. B Unnikrishnan reports additional funding from the Kasturba Medical College, Mangalore, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, India outside of the study. T Wijeratne reports additional funding from the Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Rajarata, Saliyapura, Sri Lanka outside of the study. C S Wiysonge reports additional funding from the South African Medical Research Council and the National Research Foundation of South Africa outside of the study.
year | journal | country | edition | language |
---|---|---|---|---|
2020-06-06 |