6533b86ffe1ef96bd12cdb71

RESEARCH PRODUCT

Correlated Event-by-Event Fluctuations of Flow Harmonics in Pb-Pb Collisions at sNN=2.76  TeV

L. O. D. L. PimentelRosario NaniaV. GrigorievAleksey M. TikhonovSatyajit JenaJeremy John WilkinsonAgneta OskarssonY. Corrales MoralesLukas GruberKohei TerasakiPaolo GiubellinoM. BombaraGraham Richard LeeA. MatyjaJanusz OleniaczY. BerdnikovAna VargasDanthasinghe PiyarathnaToralf Bernhard SkaaliAustin Vincent HartonManuel ColocciA. Villatoro TelloMichael Henry OliverI. Maldonado CervantesElena BrunaJacek Tomasz OtwinowskiM. R. CosentinoKlaus Johannes ReygersAstrid MorrealeE. López TorresA. KolojvariG. Martínez GarcíaM. FaselHerve BorelSilvia ArcelliP. González-zamoraMais Kazim Oglu SuleymanovLaurent DucrouxPragati SahooAlexei KhanzadeevBruno AlessandroP. H. S. Y. JayarathnaD. M. Goméz CoralAndrey ZarochentsevBogdan Theodor RascanuSk Noor AlamD. A. Moreira De GodoyH. CainesSudhir RaniwalaTatiana KaravichevaSubikash ChoudhuryM. MaseraAlexandre Alarcon Do Passo SuaideCatherine Micaela SilvestreClaudiu Cornel SchiauaSandra MorettoAndrea DanuP. Ladron De GuevaraGuillaume BatigneAjay Kumar DashBoris BatyunyaH. BøggildRajendra Nath PatraE. StenlundEdmundo Javier Garcia-solisE. FragiacomoPaolo CameriniSergey VoloshinD. MiśkowiecE. M. FioreSteffen Georg WeberWanchaloem PoonsawatVolodymyr YurchenkoAntonija UtrobicicRenu BalaAli ZamanMadan M. AggarwalJ. De CuvelandMassimiliano MarchisoneDeepa ThomasP. RosnetAndrey ReshetinSukalyan ChattopadhyayMarcello LunardonLukasz Kamil GraczykowskiD. W. KimM. Martinez PedreiraK. SchwedaM. SanoD. Domenicis GimenezJ. PlutaA. MaireAnton JuskoIvan KralikSylvain ChapelandRaphaelle Marie BailhacheAlexander KlugeIan Gardner BeardenMarco MarquardAlexey KuryakinFilimon RoukoutakisAudrey FranciscoAndry Malala RakotozafindrabeTuva Ora Herenui RichertMarkus Bernhard ZimmermannRanjit NayakBastian BathenHenrik QvigstadAnnalisa MastroserioJan Fiete Grosse-oetringhausM. NicassioIgor AltsybeevBasanta Kumar NandiKgotlaesele SenosiMichal SumberaSvein LindalRishat SultanovPing YangDennis Franz WeiserMarcel Araujo Silva FigueredoDario BerzanoAnju BhasinG. A. FeofilovV. LentiB. GrinyovUlrich FuchsCorrado GargiuloManoj Bhanudas JadhavM. BasileChristoph BlumeAndrzej RybickiP. L. M. Podesta-lermaGabriele Gaetano FronzeMarian KrivdaMikhail MalaevErin Frances GaugerVit KuceraPeter Zahariev HristovPremomoy GhoshIwona Anna SputowskaNur HussainKen OyamaJesse Thomas BuxtonVolodymyr ChelnokovAlessandro FerrettiZ. YinIonel StanRinaldo RuiH. Pereira Da CostaEvgeny RyabinkinYongwook BaekMiroslav PiknaMario SittaAttiq Ur RehmanKi-seok ChoiErmanno VercellinMotoi InabaRedmer Alexander BertensG. V. MargagliottiJin Hee YoonDavide PaganoSeyong KimQiye ShouA. Rodriguez MansoH. J. C. ZanoliJoel Anthony MazerKristin Fanebust HetlandY. F. RyabovAmalia PopRachid GuernaneChitrasen JenaCiprian Mihai MituImrich SzarkaNicole BastidLaura FabbiettiZubayer AhammedM. ZhalovMaciej Pawel SzymanskiEvgeny KryshenChristian Holm ChristensenAlexander MamonovM. Fusco GirardEsther BartschI. S. ZguraM. A. MazzoniArtem KonevskikhTahir HussainDebojit SarkarA. Karasu UysalG. PudduDaiki SekihataJ. R. M. AlmarazLevente MolnarJussi Samuli ViinikainenDmitry FinogeevA. Di MauroGrzegorz Andrzej WilkM. SpacekAndrei Ionut HerghelegiuHeiko EngelD. R. GangadharanAnkhi RoyCristina TerrevoliMatthias RichterEugen MudnicE. NappiSergey EvdokimovJason KaminRathijit BiswasI. León MonzónJozef FerenceiPeter Braun-munzingerG. S. PappalardoSanjeev Singh SambyalP. G. KuijerC. CicaloM. E. ConnorsLatchezar BetevJ. J. GaardhøjeE. Perez LezamaJohan AlmePeter GlasselN. ZaviyalovA. Gomez RamirezR. N. SingarajuJ.a. MaresF. CarnesecchiUdo Wolfgang KebschullPascal DupieuxAshik Ikbal SheikhChristian BourjauMin Jung KweonAndrea DaineseSergey FokinD. BudnikovJ. ThäderMartin PoghosyanJ. L. KlayA. R. ReolonNicolo JacazioTomoya TsujiBarbara JacakAlexander Philipp KalweitPaolo BartaliniAnte BilandzicMeike Charlotte DanischG. Herrera CorralHongbo ZhuRene BellwiedAnnika PassfeldTorsten AltFrancesco BarileMichelangelo AgnelloJaroslav AdamWladyslaw Henryk TrzaskaMadalina-gabriela TarzilaLuciano RamelloH. León VargasDmitry BlauC. RoyM. ValaM. KeilAlberto ColluE. A. R. CasulaMichal KopcikM. KimGrazia LuparelloAntoine Xavier LardeuxSamrangy SadhuRoberto PreghenellaMarek ChojnackiAlexander AkindinovVicente GonzálezJorn Henning PutschkeArseniy ShabanovMikolaj KrzewickiParaskevi GanotiRaffaele GrossoLinda VickovicRalf KeidelAlice ZimmermannKonstantin MunningLawrence PinskyS. SadovskyDomenico ColellaMartin Andreas VolklVladimir SamsonovNikola PoljakTorsten DahmsN. K. BeheraK. BarthA. ZaborowskaJoakim NystrandE. SerradillaHendrik PoppenborgLilit KarayanS. Vergara LimónNatasha SharmaMikhail IppolitovD. FabrisYonghong ZhangSergey KiselevMarton VargyasCarlos Duarte GalvanNaoto TanakaBuddhadeb BhattacharjeeMyunggeun SongSergey GorbunovChristine NattrassMonika Joanna JakubowskaI. Cortés MaldonadoGanesh Jagannath TambaveR. T. Jimenez BustamanteO. A. GrachovM. Van LeeuwenPeter LevaiMahmut OzdemirGennady ZinovjevSadhana DashAlexis Jean-michel MasJitendra KumarBoris WagnerHenner BueschingErik BrückenChiara BianchinTyler Allen BrowningDavide Francesco LodatoM. G. FleckMichael Andreas WinnSatoshi YanoMiljenko SuljicLucia LeardiniDieter RøhrichTomas Wilhelm SnellmanCristiane JahnkeGergely Gabor BarnafoldiBeomsu ChangC. OppedisanoDaniel BerenyiAndre MischkeNatalia ZhigarevaShuaib Ahmad KhanA. B. KurepinR. BelmontJ. L. CharvetMohammad Ahmad SalehJinjin PanShafiq AhmadJulien Charles HamonDavid Michael RohrJ. Castillo CastellanosLinus FeldkampAndres SandovalDirk HutterM. Rodríguez CahuantziRosario TurrisiK. ShtejerRune LangøyRoberta ArnaldiJamila Bashir ButtS. K. PalDavid H. EvansSven GotovacN. GrionWisla CarenaMartino GagliardiJurgen SchukraftEric EndressGoran SimatovicZabulon VilakaziY. SibiriakTatiana DrozhzhovaCatalin-lucian RisteaD. VranicVitaly LoginovA. K. BhatiEvgeny KondratyukA. De FalcoSang Un AhnDavid Dobrigkeit ChinellatoF. RonchettiValentina ZaccoloAndreas MorschDong-hyun KimShingo SakaiPradip Kumar SahuPaolo MartinengoNikolai SmirnovAndile Mothegi WhiteheadHans Rudolf SchmidtUwe WesterhoffFabio Filippo ColamariaSatyabrata KarVictor TrubnikovDhananjaya ThakurJ. ZhuAlexander DeistingShinichi HayashiO. Vazquez DoceTheo Alexander BrokerJørgen André LienZ. YasinRaimond SnellingsSean MurrayArturo Alejandro Menchaca-rochaIlya SelyuzhenkovP. Vande VyvreAnthony Robert TimminsChristophe FurgetAdam Ryszard KisielJean Willy Andre CleymansVolker LindenstruthDiego StoccoR. D. De SouzaFrancesco NoferiniDmitry Mal'kevichE. DénesLidia Maria GorlichKenneth Francis ReadLeonardo MilanoRaphael Noel TieulentL. AphecetcheBharati NaikY. PestovErnst HellbarJ. G. ContrerasJan CepilaTsubasa OkuboPranjal SarmaSonia ParmarJulien FaivreJ. Martin BlancoStefano PianoDavid Olle Rickard SilvermyrS. L. La PointeA. J. Rubio Montero10C. GarabatosHans Peter BeckFelix ReidtV. Chibante BarrosoT. KolleggerRaghunath SahooJan WagnerHiroshi MurakamiXiaowen RenSedat AltinpinarMartin SchmidtL. V. MalininaBruno EspagnonD. Di BariBarbara GuerzoniPetr ZávadaJihye SongGilda ScioliDeepika RatheeChristina MarkertS. EsumiA. A. VinogradovS. K. GhoshCostin GrigorasMarie GermainJai Samuel Nielsen SalzwedelMaria VasileiouA. M. RossiJ. Mercado PérezP. La RoccaPaul Christoph BätzingE. SpiritiAlberto CalivaS. P. SorensenSupriya DasArtur FursDezso VargaAndrew John LoweJ. H. KangAlexander BorissovX. CaiAlex Henri Jean ChauvinD. De GruttolaSebastian Rosado NavarroMaksym ZyzakVladislav MankoBogdan VulpescuPrabhat Ranjan PujahariPeter ChristiansenK. LapidusValerie Ramillien BarretT. K. NayakPodist KurashviliY. P. ViyogiMaciej SlupeckiF. CarenaV. PaticchioVladimir KovalenkoChristian Claude KuhnPascal DillensegerIouri BelikovThomas DietelElena RoccoH. AppelshäuserMohamad TarhiniKetil RøedSebastian LehnerSerhiy SenyukovRainer Arno Ernst RenfordtAndrew Michael KuberaP. CerelloM. A. Diaz CorcheroMohammad TariqOliver BuschPeter StrmenT. AntičićRicha GuptaChiara ZampolliSara ValleroTaku GunjiRoman LietavaP. CrochetYou ZhouVladimir PeskovA. M. GagoD. S. D. AlbuquerqueY. J. KwonOleksandr KovalenkoG. HamarJ. H. KimGiuseppe TrombettaG. Conesa BalbastrePeter Martin JacobsJon Christopher WikneStefania BufalinoPetr NomokonovV. PetrovMartin SchulcDavid HorakRashmi RaniwalaJames Declan MulliganM. IrfanGiacomo BrunoCharles E. HughesØYstein DjuvslandS. U. ChungS. MahajanT. J. HumanicL. A. P. MorenoAli OkatanChristoph MayerJacopo MarguttiMichal BrozMihai PetroviciSergey NikolaevAra GrigoryanClaude Andre PruneauT. PeitzmannD. EliaBernd Stefan WindelbandAnastasia Maria BarbanoU. FrankenfeldBenjamin Andreas HessS. K. OhAnton AlkinChaosong GaoSaikat BiswasSohail Musa MahmoodDaniel Michael MuhlheimVardanush PapikyanR. Alfaro MolinaH. Bello MartinezNicole Alice MartinSabyasachi SiddhantaIonut Christian ArseneR. ScottNilmoni SarkarAlice Elisabeth OhlsonVladimir VecherninR. H. MunzerAlexander VodopyanovAlexandr TumkinEugenio ScapparoneV. J. G. FeuillardI. K. YooShaji KumarYasuo MiakeRoberto BarberaElena BottaK. ŠAfaříkPreeti DhankherS. LiRamona LeaMihai NiculescuSergey FilchaginMarco BregantSampo SaarinenR. D. MajkaMarielle ChartierGyulnara EyyubovaTomas VanatMichael WangZhiqing ZhangGuy PaicHui ZhangE. MontesF. PrinoB. PolichtchoukIvan VorobyevSlavka JadlovskaC. PettaAlexandre ShabetaiC. Alves Garcia PradoLeonid VinogradovGabor KissDagmar AdamováPalash KhanSona PochybovaJohanna StachelKatarina Krizkova GajdosovaD. HatzifotiadouPredrag BuncicLaszlo BoldizsarJ. TakahashiAnik GuptaPaola GianottiDavide CaffarriA. Ortiz VelasquezVarlen GrabskiAnnelies Marianne VeenVito ManzariEmilia LeograndeViktor RiabovAndrea AliciS. LeePeter KalinakAstrid VauthierAlberto MasoniAndrea DublaA. J. CastroValery PuninS.a. ZaporozhetsAdriana TelescaBiswarup PaulAlessandro GrelliFiorella FiondaAlexandru Florin DobrinAjay KumarAditya Nath MishraRoberto DiviaDimitry AleksandrovS. Porteboeuf-houssaisStefano BagnascoJohannes Hendrik StillerM. V. IvanovR. Cruz AlbinoSiegfried Valentin FoertschS. K. BasuA. NedosekinXinye PengCvetan Valeriev CheshkovC. LaraCaterina DeplanoJ. BartkeDai-mei ZhouSarita SahooYvonne Chiara PachmayerPetra RiedlerJ. W. HarrisKristjan Herlache GulbrandsenCharalampos KouzinopoulosD. AlexandreA. RachevskiFabian NgAna Maria MarinC. ZhangPietro CorteseSandro BjelogrlicO. Villalobos BaillieChristian LippmannJ. W. Van HoorneR. A. RicciRadiy IlkaevV. P. KondratievMohd Danish AzmiT. BreitnerFouad RamiB. Von HallerLucina Gabriela Espinoza BeltranJohannes Peter WesselsA. Batista CamejoJeremi NiedzielaSilvia MasciocchiYves Roland SchutzPaolo PaganoPeter MalzacherKenta ShigakiR. VarmaM. I. ShahzadGiuseppe SimonettiR. OravaM. C. S. WilliamsSaehanseul OhJ. S. KimAndrey VasilievEnrico ScomparinAlla MaevskayaMuhammad Umair NaruXing Long LiJaime NormanRoy Crawford LemmonAndrea FestantiArturo TauroSoyeon ChoJana BielcikovaStefan Thomas HeckelBjarte KilengRalf Peter AverbeckS. BeoleC. Lagana FernandesGabor BiroA. C. Oliveira Da SilvaNicola BianchiAlexander SzaboFilip KrizekBranislav SitarJulius Maximilian GronefeldSidharth Kumar PrasadRenaud VernetC. Klein-bösingArild VelureKjetil UllalandN. De MarcoSanjib MuhuriP. RoyM. I. MartínezA. S. NyaninA. B. KurepinZixuan SongMirko PlaninicSonia RajputV. PetráčekRuben ShahoyanJanka VrlakovaPooja PareekJanet Elizabeth SegerLee Stuart BarnbyMihaela GheataF. BockF. BelliniNaghmeh MohammadiKishora NayakJ. JadlovskyL. NellenFederica SozziPiero GiubilatoE. Belmont-morenoJogender SainiChristian SchmidtFrancesco RiggiPanagiota FokaKilian Eberhard SchwarzM. CherneyXavier Bernard LopezJaroslav BielcikElena RogochayaMesut ArslandokJuan Carlos Cabanillas NorisMichal SefcikAndrea FrancesconS. SchuchmannZhuo ZhouRama Chandra BaralCynthia Marie HadjidakisA. Fernández TéllezMatti Mikael MieskolainenRosi ReedThomas Michael CormierPanagiotis ChristakoglouLokesh KumarMarco LeoncinoHua PeiPeter Graham JonesSmbat GrigoryanHåvard HelstrupXuan ZhangG. Koyithatta MeethaleveeduPhilipp Johannes LuettigRitsuya HosokawaTyler Harrison LutzRainer Martin SchickerBedangadas MohantyFedor GuberConstantinos LoizidesAndrzej DeloffWerner RieglerT.h. KimCristian AndreiYuri MelikyanOlja DordicVladimir IvanovG. L. UsaiAlberica ToiaMagnus MagerP. I. LoenneAnton AndronicH. J. JangVenelin AnguelovMaximiliano PuccioJ. BookAndre AugustinusFatiha LehasT. P. SinhaHanna Paulina ZbroszczykH. Natal Da LuzNatalia KondratyevaMateusz Andrzej PloskonW. J. ParkPietro AntonioliA. SharmaT. Sugitate45D. PeresunkoKirill VoloshinJan CabalaAntonio UrasLuisa CifarelliElisa MeninnoC. De ContiJ. PorterHao WangAlessandra LattucaJochen KleinBaldo SahlmullerE. Calvo VillarF. SoramelMichele FlorisJongsik EumOliver Werner ArnoldJ. CerkalaAlexandru BercuciTrine Spedstad TveterE. G. FerreiroIvan KiselY. SekiguchiM. GallioInayat Rasool BhatJacobus OnderwaaterEvgeny KarpechevG. Aglieri RinellaAdrian SevcencoFilippo CostaMichael Linus KnichelSuharyo SumowidagdoMonika KofaragoDonald M. McdonaldG. Tejeda MuñozStefan KirschSergey NikulinP. PillotJens WiechulaA. De CaroJ. Van Der MaarelP. Di NezzaPiotr Jan GasikD. WatanabeVikas SinghalUzma TabassamAntonino ZichichiGualtiero VolpeSalvatore AiolaRaymond James EhlersSibaji RahaFilip ErhardtS. BalasubramanianVladimir NikulinM. Spyropoulou-stassinakiMarcelo Gameiro MunhozValeria MucciforaA. G. BogdanovMaria HaiducVladimir KaplinBoris HippolyteVytautas VislaviciusZ. ButheleziAlina Gabriela GrigorasLivio BianchiBenjamin AudurierFederico CindoloOksana ShaduraMarek KowalskiL. ŠáNdorY. WatanabeM. A. LisaGyula BencediGideon Francois SteynM. Mohisin KhanI. BerceanuBorge Svane NielsenNikita AgrawalArtem ShangaraevMaitreyee MukherjeeElisa IncaniR. RussoKonstantin MikhaylovB. ErazmusIgor PshenichnovI. DasJ. Figiel116Jovan MilosevicM. EstienneAnders Garritt KnospeAlberto BaldisseriFederico AntinoriGerardus NoorenJan MusinskyOmbretta PinazzaHiroki YokoyamaG. De CataldoM. VeldhoenAlessandra FantoniAngela BadalaHartmut HillemannsAnand Kumar DubeyHans Martin LjunggrenP. W. StankusC. Ceballos SanchezJan PospíšilNima ZardoshtiL. CunqueiroH.b. KimRudiger HaakeStefano TrogoloD. S. HwangA. FelicielloPatrick Simon ReicheltSergey NazarenkoA. SzczepankiewiczBrigitte CheynisCarsten KleinJihyun BhomHideki HamagakiAnselmo MargottiDebasish DasM. BorriD. L. D. KeijdenerRanbir SinghMandeep KourKrzysztof Marek SielewiczMarta VerweijMalgorzata Anna JanikBoris TeyssierY. VinogradovL. Valencia PalomoElisa LaudiKrzysztof RedlichSami Sakari RasanenAshutosh PandeyJubin MitraPeter ChochulaA. S. GonzalezChengxin ZhaoChristophe Pierre SuireMukesh SharmaTeodor SiemiarczukVladimir BelyaevJ. T. BlairOleg KaravichevS. De PasqualeL. Montaño ZetinaIgor LakomovTatsuya ChujoBenjamin DonigusFranco MeddiFranck MansoHelmut Oskar OeschlerChinorat KobdajSudipan DeZ. Conesa Del ValleDong Jo KimEleazar CuautleMatej OravecØYstein Senneset HaalandFrancesco BossuB. Di RuzzaMichal MeresTiziano VirgiliCristina BeddaKatie Leanne GrahamLucile RonfletteL. Calero DiazLuciano MusaE. EppleSebastian KlewinVladimir IzucheevMarc WeberEwa Gladysz-dziadusJan RakRahul Ramachandran NairYu. V. KharlovF. ScarlassaraAdela KravcakovaI. Erdemir

subject

PhysicsLarge Hadron Collider010308 nuclear & particles physicsElliptic flowGeneral Physics and Astronomy01 natural sciencesHarmonic analysisNuclear physicsFlow (mathematics)Harmonics0103 physical sciencesQuark–gluon plasmaImpact parameterNuclear Experiment010306 general physicsEnergy (signal processing)

description

We report the measurements of correlations between event-by-event fluctuations of amplitudes of anisotropic flow harmonics in nucleus-nucleus collisions, obtained for the first time using a new analysis method based on multiparticle cumulants in mixed harmonics. This novel method is robust against systematic biases originating from non-flow effects and by construction any dependence on symmetry planes is eliminated. We demonstrate that correlations of flow harmonics exhibit a better sensitivity to medium properties than the individual flow harmonics. The new measurements are performed in Pb-Pb collisions at the centre-of-mass energy per nucleon pair of $\sqrt{s_{_{\rm NN}}}=2.76$ TeV by the ALICE experiment at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). The centrality dependence of correlation between event-by-event fluctuations of the elliptic, $v_2$, and quadrangular, $v_4$, flow harmonics, as well as of anti-correlation between $v_2$ and triangular, $v_3$, flow harmonics are presented. The results cover two different regimes of the initial state configurations: geometry-dominated (in mid-central collisions) and fluctuation-dominated (in the most central collisions). Comparisons are made to predictions from MC-Glauber, viscous hydrodynamics, AMPT and HIJING models. Together with the existing measurements of individual flow harmonics the presented results provide further constraints on initial conditions and the transport properties of the system produced in heavy-ion collisions.

https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.117.182301