6533b7d1fe1ef96bd125cda7

RESEARCH PRODUCT

Current caselaw discrepancies in the protection of national symbols and state representatives between the European Court of Human Rights and Spanish courts: a vicious circle

Andres Gascon Cuenca

subject

offenseECtHR caselawSociology and Political ScienceLlibertat d'expressiólimitationfreedom of expressionPolitical Science and International RelationsDrets humansnational symbolsstate representativesUNESCO::CIENCIAS JURÍDICAS Y DERECHOLawDret penal

description

Despite the general consensus about freedom of expression being a basic fundamental right on every democratic society, the debate about its boundaries has never found such a pacific agreement. Thus, the Spanish Penal Code has several articles that punish its abuse that are highly contested, like articles 490.3 and 543 that penalize the offenses directed towards national symbols or State representatives. This being so, this article examines the controversy generated by the application of this articles through the analysis of two judgements issued by the European Court of Human Rights against Spain, and a third one issued by the Spanish Constitutional Court that could follow the same path. This work will be done to describe the clash that exists between the caselaw of these two jurisdictions, in order to critically analyze the approach Spanish courts have to behaviors that criticize national symbols and state representatives.

yearjournalcountryeditionlanguage
2021-12-17
https://hdl.handle.net/10550/81495