6533b823fe1ef96bd127eabd

RESEARCH PRODUCT

Geo-economic variations in epidemiology, patterns of care, and outcomes in patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome: insights from the LUNG SAFE prospective cohort study

John G LaffeyFabiana MadottoGiacomo BellaniTài PhamEddy FanLaurent BrochardPravin AminYaseen ArabiEdnan K BajwaAlejandro R BruhnVladimir CernyKevin ClarksonLeo HeunksKiyoyasu KurahashiJon Henrik LaakeJose A LorenteLia McnameeNicolas NinJose Emmanuel PaloLise PiquilloudHaibo QiuJuan Ignacio Silesky JiménezAndres EstebanDaniel F McauleyFrank Van HarenMarco RanieriGordon RubenfeldHermann WriggeArthur S SlutskyAntonio PesentiJohn G. LaffeyGiacomo BellaniTai PhamEddy FanLaurent BrochardAntonio PesentiAndres EstebanLuciano GattinoniFrank Van HarenAnders LarssonDaniel F. McauleyMarco RanieriGordon RubenfeldB Taylor ThompsonHermann WriggeArthur S. SlutskyFernando RiosThierry SottiauxPieter DepuydtFredy S LoraLuciano C AzevedoGuillermo BugedoHaibo QiuMarcos GonzalezJuan SileskyVladimir CernyJonas NielsenManuel JibajaHermann WriggeDimitrios MatamisJorge L. RaneroPravin AminS.m. HashemianKevin ClarksonKiyoyasu KurahashiAsisclo VillagomezAmine Ali ZeggwaghLeo M HeunksJon Henrik LaakeJose Emmanuel PaloAntero Do Vale FernandesDorel SandescYaasen ArabiVesna BumbasierevicNicolas NinJose A. LorenteAnders LarssonLise PiquilloudFekri AbrougLia McnameeJavier HurtadoEd BajwaGabriel DémpaireHektor SulaLordian NunciAlma CaniAlan ZazuChristian DelleraRisso V AlejandroJulio DaldinRuben O FernandezLuis P CardonnetLisandro R. BettiniMariano Carboni BissoEmilio M. OsmanMariano G. SettenPablo LovazzanoJavier AlvarezVeronica VillarNorberto C. PozoNicolas GrubissichGustavo A PlotnikowDaniela N. VasquezSantiago IlutovichNorberto TiribelliAriel ChenaCarlos A. PellegriniMaría G. SaenzElisa EstenssoroMatias BrizuelaHernan GianinettoPablo E. GomezValeria I. CerratoMarco G BezziSilvina A. BorelloFlavia A. LoiaconoAdriana M. FernandezSerena KnowlesClaire ReynoldsDeborah M. InskipJennene J MillerJing KongChristina WhiteheadShailesh BihariAylin SevenAmanda KrstevskiHelen RodgersRebecca MillarToni MckennaIrene BaileyGabrielle HanlonAnders AnemanJoan LynchRaman AzadJohn NealPaul WoodsBrigit RobertsMark KolHelen WongKatharina RissThomas StaudingerXavier WitteboleCaroline BerghePierre BulpaAlain DiveRik VerstraeteHerve LebbinckJoris VermassenPhilippe MeerssemanHelga CeunenJonas RosaDaniel BeraldoClaudio PirasAdenilton RampinelliAntonio NassarSergio MatalounMarcelo MoockMarlus ThompsonClaudio GonçalvesAna AntônioAline AscoliRodrigo BiondiDanielle FonteneleDanielle NobregaVanessa SalesSuresh ShindheDk IsmailFrancois BeloncleKyle DaviesRob CironeVenika ManoharanMehvish IsmailEwan GoligherMandeep JassalErin NishikawaAreej JaveedGerard CurleyNuttapol RittayamaiMatteo ParottoNiall D FergusonSangeeta MehtaJenny KnollAntoine PronovostSergio CanestriniAlejandro BruhnPatricio GarciaFelipe AliagaPamela FaríasJacob YumhaClaudia OrtizJavier SalasAlejandro SaezLuis VegaEduardo LabarcaFelipe MartinezNicolás CarreñoPilar LoraHaitao LiuHaibo QiuLing LiuRui TangXiaoming LuoYouzhong AnHuiying ZhaoYan GaoZhe ZhaiZheng YeWei WangWenwen LiQingdong LiRuiqiang ZhengWenkui YuJuanhong ShenXinyu LiTao YuWeihua LuYa WuXiao HuangZhenyang HeYuanhua LuHui HanFan ZhangRenhua SunHua WangShu QinBao ZhuJun ZhaoJian LiuBin LiJing LiuFa ZhouQiong LiXing ZhangZhou Li-xinQiang Xin-huaLiangyan JiangYuan GaoXian ZhaoYuan LiXiao LiChunting WangQingchun YaoRongguo YuKai ChenHuanzhang ShaoBingyu QinQing HuangWei ZhuAi HangMa HuaYimin LiYonghao XuYu DiLong LingTie QinShou WangJunping QinYi HanSuming ZhouMonica VargasJuan JimenezManuel RojasJaime Solis-quesadaChristian Ramirez-alfaroJan MácaPeter SklienkaJakob GjedstedAage ChristiansenJonas NielsenBoris VillamaguaMiguel LlanoPhilippe BurtinGautier BuzancaisPascal BeuretNicolas PelletierSatar MortazaAlain MercatJonathan ChellySébastien JochmansNicolas TerziCédric DaubinGuillaume CarteauxNicolas De ProstJean-daniel ChicheFabrice DaviaudTai PhamMuriel FartoukhGuillaume BarberetJerome BiehlerJean DellamonicaDenis DoyenJean-michel ArnalAnais BriquetSami HraiechLaurent PapazianDamien RouxJonathan MessikaEvangelos KalaitzisLaurence DangersAlain CombesSiu-ming AuGaetan BéduneauDorothée CarpentierElie ZogheibHerve DupontSylvie RicomeFrancesco SantoliSebastien BessetPhilippe MichelBruno GeléePierre-eric DaninBernard GoubauxPhilippe CrovaNga PhanFrantz BerkelmansJulio BadieRomain TapponnierJosette GallySamy KhebbebJean-etienne HerbrechtFrancis SchneiderPierre-louis DeclercqJean-philippe RigaudJacques DuranteauAnatole HarroisRussell ChabanneJulien MarinCharlene BigotSandrine ThibaultMohammed GhaziMessabi BoukhaznaSalem ZeinJack RichecoeurDaniele CombauxFabien GrelonCharlene Le MoalElise SauvadetAdrien RobineVirginie LemialeDanielle ReuterMartin DresAlexandre DemouleDany Goldgran-toledanoLoredana BaboiClaude GuérinRalph LohnerJens KraßlerSusanne SchäferKai ZacharowskiPatrick MeybohmAndreas ReskePhilipp SimonHans-bernd HopfMichael SchuetzThomas BaltusMetaxia PapanikolaouTheonymfi PapavasilopoulouGiannis ZacharasVasilis OurailogloyEleni MouloudiEleni MassaEva NagyElectra StamouEllada KiourtzievaMarina OikonomouLuis AvilaCesar CortezJohanna CitalánSameer JogSafal SableBhagyesh ShahMohan GurjarArvind BaroniaMohammedfaruk MemonRadhakrishnan MuthuchellappanVenkatapura RameshAnitha ShenoyRamesh UnnikrishnanSubhal DixitRachana RhayakarNagarajan RamakrishnanVallish BhardwajHeera MahtoSudha SagarVijayanand PalaniswamyDeeban GanesanSeyed HashemianHamidreza JamaatiFarshad HeidariEdel MeaneyAlistair NicholKarl KnapmanDonall O'croininEimhin DunneDorothy M BreenKevin ClarksonRola JaafarRory DwyerFahd AmirOlaitan AjetunmobiAogan O'muircheartaighColin BlackNuala TreanorDaniel CollinsWahid AltafGianluca ZaniMaurizio FusariSavino SpadaroCarlo VoltaRomano GrazianiBarbara BrunettiniSalvatore PalmesePaolo FormentiMichele UmbrelloAndrea LombardoElisabetta PecciMarc BotteriMonica SavioliAlessandro ProttiAlessia MatteiLorenzo SchiavoniAndrea TinnirelloManuel TodeschiniAntonino GiarratanoAndrea CortegianiSara SherAnna RossiMassimo AntonelliLuca MontiniPaolo CasalenaSergio ScafettiGiovanna PanarelloGiovanna OcchipintiNicolò PatronitiMatteo PozziRoberto BiscioneMichela PoliFerdinando RaimondiDaniela AlbieroGiulia CrapelliEduardo BeckVincenzo PotaVincenzo SchiavoneAlexandre MolinFabio TarantinoGiacomo MontiElena FratiLucia MirabellaGilda CinnellaTommaso FossaliRiccardo ColomboPierpaolo TerragniIlaria PattarinoFrancesco MojoliAntonio BraschiErika BorottoAndrea CracchioloDaniela PalmaFrancesco RaponiGiuseppe FotiEttore VascottoAndrea CoppadoroLuca BrazziLeda FlorisGiorgio IottiAaron VentiOsamu YamaguchiShunsuke TakagiHiroki MaeyamaEizo WatanabeYoshihiro YamajiKazuyoshi ShimizuKyoko ShiozakiSatoru FutamiSekine RyosukeKoji SaitoYoshinobu KameyamaKeiko UenoMasayo IzawaNao OkudaHiroyuki SuzukiTomofumi HarasawaMichitaka NasuTadaaki TakadaFumihito ItoShin NunomiyaKansuke KoyamaToshikazu AbeKohkichi AndohKohei KusumotoAkira HirataAkihiro TakabaHiroyasu KimuraShuhei MatsumotoUshio HigashijimaHiroyuki HondaNobumasa AokiHiroshi ImaiYasuaki OginoIchiko MizuguchiKazuya IchikadoKenichi NittaKatsunori MochizukiTomoaki HashidaHiroyuki TanakaTomoyuki NakamuraDaisuke NiimiTakeshi UedaYozo KashiwaAkinori UchiyamaOlegs SabelnikovsPeteris OssYoussef HaddadKong LiewSilvio ÑAmendys-silvaYves Jarquin-badiolaLuis Sanchez-hurtadoSaira Gomez-floresMaria MarinAsisclo VillagomezJordana LemusJonathan FierroMavy CervantesFrancisco MejiaDulce M. DectorDaniel GonzalezClaudia EstrellaJorge Sanchez-medinaAlvaro Ramirez-gutierrezFernando GeorgeJanet AguirreJuan BuensusesoManuel PoblanoTarek DendaneAmine ZeggwaghHicham BalkhiMina ElkhayariNacer SamkaouiHanane EzzouineAbdellatif BenslamaMourad AmorWajdi MaazouziNedim CimicOliver BeckMonique BrunsJeroen SchoutenMyra RiniaMonique RaaijmakersLeo HeunksHellen Van WezelSerge J HeinesUlrich StrauchFabienne SimonisJennifer GoodsonTroy BrowneLeanlove NavarraAnna HuntRobyn HutchisonMathew BaileyLynette NewbyColin McarthurMichael KalkoffAlex McleodJonathan CasementDanielle HackingFinn AndersenMerete DolvaJon LaakeAndreas Barratt-dueKim NoremarkEldar SøreideBrit SjøbøAnne GuttormsenHector YoshidoRonald AguilarFredy OscanoaAlain AlisasisJoanne RoblesRossini Pasanting-limBeatriz TanPawel AndruszkiewiczKarina JakubowskaCristina CoxoAntónio AlvarezBruno OliveiraGustavo MontanhaNelson C BarrosCarlos PereiraAntónio MessiasJorge MonteiroAna AraujoNuno CatorzeSusan MarumMaria BouwRui GomesVania BritoSilvia CastroJoana EstilitaFilipa BarrosIsabel SerraAurelia MartinhoDana R TomescuAlexandra MarcuOvidiu BedreagMarius PapuricaDan CorneciSilvius NegoitaEvgeny GrigorievAlexey I GritsanAndrey GazenkampfGhaleb AlmekhlafiMohamad AlbarrakGhanem MustafaKhalid MaghrabiNawal SalahuddinTharwat AisaAhmed Al JabbaryEdgardo TabhanYaseen ArabiOlivia TrinidadHasan M Al DorziEdgardo TabhanStefan BolonOliver SmithJordi ManceboHernan Aguirre-bermeoJuan Lopez-delgadoFrancisco EsteveGemma RialpCatalina FortezaCandelaria De HaroGuillermo AlbaicetaSara De Cima-iglesiasLeticia Seoane-quirogaAlexandra Ceniceros-barrosAntonio Ruiz-aguilarLuis Claraco-vegaJuan SolerMaria Del Carmen LorenteCecilia HermosaFederico GordoMiryam Prieto-gonzálezJuan López-messaManuel PerezCesar PerezRaquel AllueFerran Roche-campoMarcos Ibañez-santacruzSusana TempranoMaria PintadoRaul De PabloPilar GómezSilvia RuizSilvia MolesTeresa JuradoAlfons ArizmendiEnrique PiacentiniNieves FrancoTeresa HonrubiaMeisy ChengElena LosadaJavier BlancoLuis YusteCecilia Carbayo-gorrizFrancisca Cazorla-barranqueroJavier AlonsoRosa AldaÁNgela AlgabaGonzalo NavarroEnrique CereijoEsther Diaz-rodriguezDiego MarcosLaura MonteroLuis ParaRoberto SanchezMiguel NavalpotroRicardo AbadRaquel GonzálezDácil ToribioAlejandro CastroMaria ArtigaOscar PenuelasTomas RoserMoreno OlgaElena CurtoRocío SánchezVallverdu ImmaGarcia ElisabetLaura ClaveriasMonica MagretAna PellicerLucia RodriguezJesús Sánchez-ballesterosÁNgela González-salamancaAntonio JimenezFrancisco HuertaJuan DiazEsther LopezDavid MoyaAlec AlfonsoPalazon LuisPalazon CesarSánchez RafaelCorcoles VirgilioNoelia RecioRichard AdamssonChristian RylanderBernhard HolzgraefeLars BromanJoanna WessberghLinnea PerssonFredrik SchiölerHans KedelvAnna TibblinHenrik AppelbergLars HedlundJohan HellebergKarin ErikssonRita GlietschNiklas LarssonIngela NygrenSilvia NunesAnna-karin MorinThomas KanderAnne AdolfssonLise PiquilloudHervé ZenderCorinne Leemann-refondiniSouheil ElatrousSlaheddine BouchouchaImed ChoucheneIslem OuanesAsma SouissiSalma KamounOktay DemirkiranMustafa AkerEmre ErbabacanIlkay CeylanNermin GirginMenekse OzcelikNecmettin ÜNalBasak MecoOnat AkyolSuleyman DermanBarry KennedyKen ParharLatha SrinivasaLia McnameeDanny McauleyPhil HopkinsClare MellisVivek KakarDan HadfieldAndre VercueilKaushik BhowmickSally HumphreysAndrew FergusonRaymond MckeeAshok RajDanielle FawkesPhilip WattLinda TwoheyRajeev JhaMatthew ThomasAlex MortonVarsha KadabaMark SmithAnil HormisSanthana KannanMiriam NamihHenrik ReschreiterJulie CamsooksaiAlek KumarSzabolcs RugonfalviChristopher NuttOrla O'neillColette SeasmanGed DempseyChristopher ScottHelen EllisStuart MckkechniePaula HuttonNora Di TomassoMichela VitaleRuth GriffinMichael DeanJulius CranshawEmma WillettNicholas IoannouSarah GillisPeter CsabiRosaleen MacfadyenHeidi DawsonPieter PreezAlexandra WilliamsOwen BoydLaura De GordoaJon BramallSophie SymmondsSimon ChauTim WenhamTamas SzakmanyPiroska Toth-tarsolyKatie MccalmanPeter AlexanderLorraine StephensonThomas CollyerRhiannon ChapmanRaphael CooperRussell AllanMalcolm SimDavid WrathallDonald IrvineKim ZantuaJohn AdamsAndrew BurtenshawGareth SellorsIngeborg WeltersKaren WilliamsRobert HessellMatthew OldroydCeri E BattleSuresh PillaiIstvan KajtorMageswaran SivashanmugavelSinead O'kaneAdrian DonnellyAniko FrigyikJon CarelessMartin MayRichard StewartT. John TrinderSamantha HaganMatt WiseJade ColeCaroline MacfieAnna DowlingJavier HurtadoNicolás NinEdgardo NuñezGustavo PittiniRuben RodriguezMaría ImperioCristina SantosAna FrançaAlejandro EbeidAlberto DeicasCarolina SerraAditya UppalapatiGhassan KamelValerie Banner-goodspeedJeremy BeitlerSatyanarayana MukkeraShreedhar KulkarniJarone LeeTomaz MesarJohn ShinnDina GomaaChristopher TainterJarone LeeTomaz MesarJarone LeeDale YeattsJessica WarrenMichael LanspaRussel MillerColin GrissomSamuel BrownPhilippe BauerRyan GosselinBarrett KitchJason CohenScott BeegleRenaud GueretAiman TulaimatShazia ChoudryWilliam StiglerHitesh BatraNidhi HuffKeith LambTrevor OettingNicholas MohrClaine JudyShigeki SaitoFayez KheirFayez KheirAdam SchlichtingAngela DelsingDaniel CrouchMary ElmasriDaniel CrouchDina IsmailKyle DreyerThomas BlakemanKyle DreyerDina GomaaRebecca BaronCarolina GrijalbaPeter HouRaghu SeethalaImo AisikuGalen HendersonSen-kuang HouRobert OwensAshley SchomerVesna BumbasirevicBojan JovanovicMaja SurbatovicMilic Veljovic

subject

MaleARDSdemographyeconomicmedicine.medical_treatmentTerapéuticaair conditioningComorbidityintensive care unitdeveloped country0302 clinical medicineneuromuscular blockingmiddle agedacute myocardial-infarctionmiddle income countryProspective StudiesGeography Medicalcritically-ill patientsadultagedpriority journalrisk factorIncomegeographic-variationDeveloped countryhospitalizationprospective studyHumanPulmonary and Respiratory MedicineDeveloped Countriemedicine.medical_specialtyDeveloping countryArticle/dk/atira/pure/subjectarea/asjc/2700/274003 medical and health sciencesSíndrome respiratorio agudo graveunitsMedicalHumansIntensive care medicineDeveloping CountriesAgedhigh income countryRespiratory Distress Syndrome Adultnoninvasive ventilationAparato respiratoriomedicine.diseasemortalitymajor clinical studyProspective Studiearterial oxygen tension030228 respiratory systemARDSObservational studySociologíahealth care deliverygeographyintensive-careRisk FactorsEpidemiologyProspective cohort studyRespiratory Distress Syndromepartial pressureartificial ventilationSociología médicaMiddle Agedadult respiratory distress syndromeAged; Comorbidity; Delivery of Health Care; Developed Countries; Developing Countries; Europe; Female; Geography Medical; Humans; Income; Intensive Care Units; Male; Middle Aged; Patient Outcome Assessment; Prospective Studies; Respiratory Distress Syndrome Adult; Risk Factors; Pulmonary and Respiratory MedicineEuropeIntensive Care UnitsfemaleincomeFemaleEnfermedadinjurycohort analysigross national incomesurvivalNOmedical geographyDeveloping Countrielength of staymedicinecontrolled studyoutcome assessmentbreast-cancerMechanical ventilationdiseasebusiness.industryDeveloped Countriespatient caredeveloping country030208 emergency & critical care medicinestatistics and numerical data AgedComorbiditywinterACUTE MYOCARDIAL-INFARCTION; CRITICALLY-ILL PATIENTS; GEOGRAPHIC-VARIATION; INTENSIVE-CARE; BREAST-CANCER; MORTALITY; DISEASE; INJURY; UNITS; HOSPITALIZATIONPatient Outcome AssessmentEmergency medicineprone positiontreatment outcomebusinessDelivery of Health Care

description

Background Little information is available about the geo-economic variations in demographics, management, and outcomes of patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). We aimed to characterise the effect of these geo-economic variations in patients enrolled in the Large Observational Study to Understand the Global Impact of Severe Acute Respiratory Failure (LUNG SAFE). Methods LUNG SAFE was done during 4 consecutive weeks in winter, 2014, in a convenience sample of 459 intensive-care units in 50 countries across six continents. Inclusion criteria were admission to a participating intensive-care unit (including transfers) within the enrolment window and receipt of invasive or non-invasive ventilation. One of the trial's secondary aims was to characterise variations in the demographics, management, and outcome of patients with ARDS. We used the 2016 World Bank countries classification to define three major geo-economic groupings, namely European high-income countries (Europe-High), high-income countries in the rest of the world (rWORLD-High), and middle-income countries (Middle). We compared patient outcomes across these three groupings. LUNG SAFE is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT02010073. Findings Of the 2813 patients enrolled in LUNG SAFE who fulfilled ARDS criteria on day 1 or 2, 1521 (54%) were recruited from Europe-High, 746 (27%) from rWORLD-High, and 546 (19%) from Middle countries. We noted significant geographical variations in demographics, risk factors for ARDS, and comorbid diseases. The proportion of patients with severe ARDS or with ratios of the partial pressure of arterial oxygen (PaO2) to the fractional concentration of oxygen in inspired air (FiO2) less than 150 was significantly lower in rWORLD-High countries than in the two other regions. Use of prone positioning and neuromuscular blockade was significantly more common in Europe-High countries than in the other two regions. Adjusted duration of invasive mechanical ventilation and length of stay in the intensive-care unit were significantly shorter in patients in rWORLD-High countries than in Europe-High or Middle countries. High gross national income per person was associated with increased survival in ARDS; hospital survival was significantly lower in Middle countries than in Europe-High or rWORLD-High countries. Interpretation Important geo-economic differences exist in the severity, clinician recognition, and management of ARDS, and in patients' outcomes. Income per person and outcomes in ARDS are independently associated. European Society of Intensive Care Medicine, St Michael's Hospital, University of Milan-Bicocc 21.466 JCR (2017) Q1, 1/33 Critical Care Medicine 7.746 SJR (2017) Q1, 1/152 Pulmonary and Respiratory Medicine No data IDR 2017 UEM

10.1016/s2213-2600(17)30213-8http://hdl.handle.net/11585/667244