6533b831fe1ef96bd1299a15

RESEARCH PRODUCT

Global, regional, and national levels of maternal mortality, 1990–2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015

Atsede Fantahun AregayXiaofeng LiangFabiola Mejía-rodríguezRajesh SagarMeghan D. MooneyJoão Vasco SantosAkindele Olupelumi AdebiyiVesper Hichilombwe ChisumpaVesper Hichilombwe ChisumpaHjalte Holm AndersenAmiran GamkrelidzeMichael R. PhillipsMichael R. PhillipsRoberto Tchio TalongwaNancy FullmanManisha DubeyYichong LiYichong LiAlireza MohammadiSamath D DharmaratneRobert P. DellavalleGeorge Mugambage RuhagoAlbertino DamascenoShireen SindiBenn SartoriusMete SaylanKonstantin KazanjanNaohiro YonemotoFrida Namnyak NgalesoniHans W. HoekHans W. HoekDavid C. SchwebelSanjay ZodpeyLorenzo MonastaSungho WonZiyad Al-alyAdugnaw BerhaneCharles Shey WiysongeCharles Shey WiysongeMaria Dolores Sanchez-niñoTesfaye TekleAbdishakur M. AbdulleJean B. NachegaJean B. NachegaJean B. NachegaHamid AsayeshJost B. JonasYoung-ho KhangFerrán Catalá-lópezFerrán Catalá-lópezTolesa BekeleMichael BraininElizabeth GlaserZiad A. MemishIbrahim AbubakarPedro R. OlivaresBach Xuan TranBach Xuan TranJasvinder A. SinghKonstantinos StroumpoulisSteven E. LipshultzSteven E. LipshultzMegan CoggeshallRose Mayerline AntoineVasiliki StathopoulouAzeem MajeedRafael Tabarés-seisdedosEdem DossouNikolaos PapantoniouSamer HamidiYang LiuHeidi J. LarsonHeidi J. LarsonTeshome GebreBoris BikbovNoore AlamNoore AlamCharles D.a. WolfeCharles D.a. WolfeUlrich O MuellerAzmeraw T. AmareKatherine B GibneyKatherine B GibneyFrancesco Saverio ViolanteMonika SawhneyEyal OrenPeter Njenga KeiyoroStein Emil VollsetStein Emil VollsetStein Emil VollsetAndrea WerdeckerRosana E. NormanDevasahayam J. ChristopherRicky LeungJulio Cesar Montañez HernandezFarshad PourmalekMaryam S. FarvidRuoyan Tobe-gaiTill BärnighausenTill BärnighausenInge HuybrechtsInge HuybrechtsSemaw Ferede AberaSemaw Ferede AberaDevina NandDavid M. PereiraSadaf G. SepanlouBemnet Amare TedlaBemnet Amare TedlaWorku TeferaMarika NomuraPeter AzzopardiPeter AzzopardiHsing-yi ChangHsing-yi ChangChandrasekharan Nair KesavachandranHaidong WangYongmei LiYongmei LiZahid A ButtRaimundas LuneviciusSuzanne PolinderGuoqing HuYousef KhaderAmanuel Tesfay GebremedhinAmanuel Tesfay GebremedhinMaziar Moradi-lakehAndrew H. KempAndrew H. KempCarla Makhlouf ObermeyerIn-hwan OhEdgar P. SimardLuke NyakarahukaSergey K VladimirovAliasghar Ahmad KiadaliriAliasghar Ahmad KiadaliriYuichiro YanoHilton LamAman Yesuf EndriesRosario CárdenasRahman ShiriDaniel C CaseySibhatu BiadgilignLuke D. KnibbsBalem Demtsu BetsuBryan L. SykesAbdullah Sulieman TerkawiAbdullah Sulieman TerkawiEmerito Jose A. FaraonAl ArtamanAmanda J. Mason-jonesKaja AbbasSuzanne Barker-colloAref A. Bin AbdulhakBolajoko OlusanyaTommi VasankariAliya NaheedCaitlyn SteinerAndre P KengneAndre Pascal KengneGholamreza RoshandelGholamreza RoshandelXie Rachel KulikoffNataliya FoigtAmi R. MooreNaris SilpakitMarie NgMaigeng ZhouMaigeng ZhouThomas FlemingLela SturuaAndrew L. Thorne-lymanAndrew L. Thorne-lymanDenis NashNobuyuki HoritaJeffrey A. TowbinJeffrey A. TowbinRajiv ChowdhuryDonal BisanzioHilda L HarbJiabin ShenJiabin ShenKossivi Agbelenko AfanviSuleman AtiqueShicheng YuGuohong JiangJoseph A WagnerCarlos A Castañeda-orjuelaNeeraj Haidong WangLuca RonfaniInga Dora SigfusdottirHaidong KanFelix MasiyeEun-kee ParkSubas NeupaneJohn J HuangMuhammad Imran NisarVirendra SinghGlen MolaChristine PinhoJulio Cesar Campuzano RinconOlalekan A. UthmanLaxmikant ChavanHéctor Lamadrid-figueroaRafael LozanoDamian G HoyBineyam TayeNeal D. FutranRobert W AldridgePaulo A. LotufoSajjad Ur RahmanDaniel DickerSameer Vali GopalaniTasara T. MazorodzeKenji ShibuyaMaysaa El Sayed ZakiShiwei LiuAlireza EsteghamatiSeok Jun YoonMiia KivipeltoDharmesh Kumar LalKaren M. TabbJoseph R FitchettTheo VosTuomo J. MeretojaAlemseged Aregay GebruChanda KulkarniOluremi N AjalaOluremi N AjalaP. V. RaoValentina Arsić ArsenijevićValentina Arsić ArsenijevićBarthelemy Kuate DefoCarla Sofia E Sa FarinhaYun Jin KimNicholas GraetzErika OtaBabak EshratiFrançois AllaAla'a AlkerwiElena Alvarez MartinRajesh SharmaMichael KutzOm Prakash SinghPatrick LiuHenock YebyoHenock YebyoAlan D. LopezAlan D. LopezEuripide Frinel G Arthur AvokpahoChristopher J L MurrayChioma Ezinne ChibuezeSamir SonejiHsiang HuangYoshihiro KokuboTukur DahiruJung-chen ChangLuciano A. SposatoKingsley N. UkwajaMaya S FraserJohn N NewtonTom AchokiH. Dean HosgoodLinhong WangG Anil KumarJoão C. FernandesRajesh Kumar RaiIsmael R. Campos-nonatoKathryn H. JacobsenRasmus HavmoellerKonrad PesudovsVictor AboyansPablo MonteroMengistu GebremedhinHye Youn ParkTariku JibatTariku JibatElisabeth Barboza FrançaSamia AlhabibMin-jeong ShinLalit DandonaLalit DandonaAmitava BanerjeeZubair KabirAlexis J HandalKaren SliwaMustafa Z. YounisPadukudru Anand MaheshAleksandra BaracSimon I. HaySimon I. HayBulat IdrisovStefan MaStefan MaGraeme J. HankeyPrashant SinghSoumya SwaminathanQuyen NguyenTesfaye SetegnSamantha M. ColquhounSergey Petrovich ErmakovSrinivas MurthyPeter NguhiuFarshad FarzadfarChristian Lycke EllingsenOle Frithjof NorheimZulfiqar A. BhuttaZulfiqar A BhuttaRintaro MoriHajo ZeebEduardo BernabéNadia AkseerMaheswar SatpathyAlaa BadawiAlaa BadawiAung Soe HtetJames LeighGelin XuMarissa IannaroneYi ZhaoYi ZhaoAjit Kumar YadavAdeladza Kofi AmegahJee-young Jasmine ChoiKetevan GambashidzeReed J D SorensenJohan ÄRnlövJohan ÄRnlövLiliana G CiobanuSanjay KrishnaswamiScott B. PattenPeter W. GethingKalpana BalakrishnanFisaha Haile TesfayFisaha Haile TesfayMarcella MonticoMojde MirarefinMaia KereselidzeNeal MarquezMostafa QorbaniAmare DeribewAmare DeribewDon C. Des JarlaisDon C. Des JarlaisAmany H RefaatAmany H RefaatRuben CastroFiorella CavalleriSara SheikhbahaeiIsabela M. BenseñorLuigi NaldiNiveen M E Abu-rmeilehAchala Upendra JayatillekeTissa WijeratneGiuseppe RemuzziAmir KasaeianJuan SanabriaJuan SanabriaMarina Shakh-nazarovaGudlavalleti V S MurthyGudlavalleti V S MurthyStephen M. AmrockMohammad TavakkoliAndre KerenKalkidan Hassen AbateThomas FürstThomas FürstThomas FürstAnders LarssonStan BiryukovTed R. MillerTed R. MillerNicholas J KassebaumEjaz Ahmad KhanAmbuj RoyYibeltal Tebekaw BayouChandrashekhar T SreeramareddyRyan M BarberRodrigo Sarmiento-suarezUmar BachaArdeshir KhosraviYong ZhaoYong ZhaoJoseph FriedmanMax PetzoldGregory M AndersonBurcu Kucuk BicerYohannes KinfuAmador GoodridgeTsegaye Tewelde GebrehiwotMahfuzar RahmanHadi DanawiRoman Topor-madryRoman Topor-madryShahrzad Bazargan-hejaziShahrzad Bazargan-hejaziShahrzad Bazargan-hejaziFelix Akpojene OgboAlan J ThomsonKim Moesgaard IburgRahimi-movaghar VReza MalekzadehJessica M. SmithKatya Anne ShackelfordFlorian FischerMan Mohan MehndirattaSolomon Meseret WoldeyohannesGessessew Bugssa HailuMohammed Magdy Abd El RazekScott WeichenthalMihajlo JakovljevicKawkab ShishaniNorberto PericoVinay NangiaAndré FaroAustin CarterChuanhua YuSun Ha JeeRandah R. HamadehBruno F. SunguyaDerrick A BennettAtte MeretojaAtte MeretojaMonica CortinovisDeena AlasfoorBeth E. EbelGirma Temam ShifaMohsen NaghaviPhilimon GonaJonathan I. SilverbergFrancis Apolinary MhimbiraRajeev GuptaTomi AkinyemijuMuhammad Muhammad SalehDimitris KarletsosRonny WestermanVegard SkirbekkVegard SkirbekkChhabi Lal RanabhatSoewarta KosenAtsushi GotoFoluke Adetola OjelabiGeorge A. MensahAbayomi Samuel OyekaleLeslie T. CooperMassimo CirilloWalter MendozaAshish AwasthiIqbal R. F. ElyazarMegha AroraJulian David PillayVinod K. PaulCassandra SzoekeNelson Alvis-guzmanTigist Assefa BayouArsène Kouablan AdouShafiu MohammedShafiu MohammedJohanna M. GeleijnseAmanuel Alemu AbajobirRaghib AliSoraya SeedatAndreas A KudomVasiliy Victorovich VlassovRatilal LallooBelinda K LloydBelinda K LloydPanniyammakal JeemonAndré KarchRobert G. WeintraubRobert G. WeintraubIone Jayce Ceola SchneiderJed D. BloreAli H. MokdadAngel Paternina-caicedoEric L. DingNarayanaswamy VenketasubramanianVeena R. IyerWalid AmmarStephen S LimIsaac Akinkunmi AdedejiEspen BjertnessYing JiangPaul S. F. YipGrant NguyenKhurshid AlamKhurshid AlamIrma KhonelidzeAi KoyanagiHarish Chander GugnaniMiloje SavicMelvin Barrientos MarzanPeter A. MeaneyMohammad Hifz Ur RahmanLidia MorawskaJames D. WilkinsonJames D. WilkinsonKebede DeribeKebede DeribeAbera Kenay TuraAbera Kenay TuraSergey SoshnikovJamie HancockYohannes Adama MelakuYohannes Adama MelakuIvy ShiueIvy ShiueAlexandra BrazinovaNader JahanmehrYuming GuoValentina ColistroJagdish KhubchandaniTraolach S. BrughaMichelle L. BellAmanda W PainBrian J. BiroscakBrian J. BiroscakEdward J MillsAbdur Rahman KhanVipin GuptaNima Hafezi-nejadHéctor Gómez-dantésAlemayehu AmberbirJohn Nelson OpioMatthew M CoatesArnav AgarwalArnav AgarwalSivadasanpillai HarikrishnanTalha FaridBediAyalnesh Zemene YalewJun SheBeatriz Paulina Ayala QuintanillaBeatriz Paulina Ayala QuintanillaBereket YakobDayane Gabriele Alves SilveiraSaleh F. AldhahriUsha RamQingyang XiaoJoan B. SorianoRitul KamalShifalika GoenkaParvaiz A KoulEdson Serván-moriAnil KaulItamar S. SantosFoad Abd-allahMarek MajdanRahul GuptaNorlinah Mohamed IbrahimAnwar RafayJacob Olusegun OlusanyaJosé NevesDavid Rojas-ruedaRakhi DandonaStefanos TyrovolasZacharie Tsala DimbueneJeanne Françoise KayibandaAlemayehu B. MekonnenAlemayehu B. MekonnenAddisu Shunu BeyeneMelkamu Dedefo GishuAdemola Lukman AdelekanJoshua A. SalomonSeyed-mohammad FereshtehnejadMamo WubshetSerge ResnikoffLiesl ZühlkeFarhad PishgarUbai AlsharifRichard C. FranklinJonathan De La Cruz MonisDiego Augusto Santos SilvaCyrus CooperCyrus CooperDiego De LeoRajaa Al-raddadiAmber SligarChantal HuynhMahmud A. AbdallatMaurice GiroudMasood Ali ShaikhMehdi JavanbakhtDaniel PopeThara RangaswamyAlemayehu HailuAwoke MisganawNorito KawakamiCarl Abelardo T. AntonioAbhishek SinghNicholas J K BreitbordeKazem RahimiVivekanand JhaVivekanand JhaGizachew Assefa TessemaGizachew Assefa TessemaAlem MehariWagner MarcenesChabila C MapomaLaura KemmerDavid J. MargolisAbabi Zergaw GirefTimothy M. WolockDhruv S. KaziQing LanKimani M HarunKimani M HarunZoubida ZaidiHassan Magdy Abd El RazekMasako HorinoDennis Odai LaryeaJustin BeardsleyKarzan Abdulmuhsin MohammadElisabete WeiderpassJuan Jesus CarreroSanjay BasuMaria Cecilia Bahit

subject

0301 basic medicinePediatricsNutrition and DiseaseMILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALSSUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALSANTENATAL CAREGlobal Health0302 clinical medicineVoeding en Ziekte11. SustainabilityGlobal healthHQHealthcare FinancingEMERGENCY OBSTETRIC CARE030212 general & internal medicineCooperative Behavior10. No inequalityReproductive healthMedicine(all)education.field_of_study030219 obstetrics & reproductive medicineMedicine (all)1. No povertyObstetrics and GynecologyPublic Health Global Health Social Medicine and EpidemiologyPrenatal CareGeneral Medicine11 Medical And Health SciencesLOW-RESOURCE SETTINGS3142 Public health care science environmental and occupational healthFamily Planning Service3. Good healthGBD 2015 Maternal Mortality CollaboratorsGovernment ProgramsMaternal MortalityReproductive HealthFamily Planning ServicesMaternal deathHEALTHLife Sciences & BiomedicineHumanCOUNTRIESmedicine.medical_specialtyPopulation610Prenatal careArticle03 medical and health sciencesMedicine General & InternalSDG 3 - Good Health and Well-beingCASH TRANSFER PROGRAMEnvironmental healthGeneral & Internal Medicineparasitic diseasesmedicineLife ScienceQUALITYHumansGlobal Burden of Disease StudyeducationVLAGScience & TechnologyMedical Assistancebusiness.industryKlinisk medicinParturitionObstetric transitionmedicine.diseaseQPInfant mortalityFolkhälsovetenskap global hälsa socialmedicin och epidemiologiStandardized mortality ratio030104 developmental biologyRISK-FACTORSRGClinical MedicinebusinessRA

description

BACKGROUND: In transitioning from the Millennium Development Goal to the Sustainable Development Goal era, it is imperative to comprehensively assess progress toward reducing maternal mortality to identify areas of success, remaining challenges, and frame policy discussions. We aimed to quantify maternal mortality throughout the world by underlying cause and age from 1990 to 2015.METHODS: We estimated maternal mortality at the global, regional, and national levels from 1990 to 2015 for ages 10-54 years by systematically compiling and processing all available data sources from 186 of 195 countries and territories, 11 of which were analysed at the subnational level. We quantified eight underlying causes of maternal death and four timing categories, improving estimation methods since GBD 2013 for adult all-cause mortality, HIV-related maternal mortality, and late maternal death. Secondary analyses then allowed systematic examination of drivers of trends, including the relation between maternal mortality and coverage of specific reproductive health-care services as well as assessment of observed versus expected maternal mortality as a function of Socio-demographic Index (SDI), a summary indicator derived from measures of income per capita, educational attainment, and fertility.FINDINGS: Only ten countries achieved MDG 5, but 122 of 195 countries have already met SDG 3.1. Geographical disparities widened between 1990 and 2015 and, in 2015, 24 countries still had a maternal mortality ratio greater than 400. The proportion of all maternal deaths occurring in the bottom two SDI quintiles, where haemorrhage is the dominant cause of maternal death, increased from roughly 68% in 1990 to more than 80% in 2015. The middle SDI quintile improved the most from 1990 to 2015, but also has the most complicated causal profile. Maternal mortality in the highest SDI quintile is mostly due to other direct maternal disorders, indirect maternal disorders, and abortion, ectopic pregnancy, and/or miscarriage. Historical patterns suggest achievement of SDG 3.1 will require 91% coverage of one antenatal care visit, 78% of four antenatal care visits, 81% of in-facility delivery, and 87% of skilled birth attendance.INTERPRETATION: Several challenges to improving reproductive health lie ahead in the SDG era. Countries should establish or renew systems for collection and timely dissemination of health data; expand coverage and improve quality of family planning services, including access to contraception and safe abortion to address high adolescent fertility; invest in improving health system capacity, including coverage of routine reproductive health care and of more advanced obstetric care-including EmOC; adapt health systems and data collection systems to monitor and reverse the increase in indirect, other direct, and late maternal deaths, especially in high SDI locations; and examine their own performance with respect to their SDI level, using that information to formulate strategies to improve performance and ensure optimum reproductive health of their population.FUNDING: Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

10.1016/s0140-6736(16)31470-2http://hdl.handle.net/11585/585328