6533b82efe1ef96bd1293abd

RESEARCH PRODUCT

Constraining the p -Mode– g -Mode Tidal Instability with GW170817

P. OppermannP. OppermannR. MittlemanNelson ChristensenNelson ChristensenK. E. RamirezD. MoffaJ. J. MccannT. J. Slaven-blairS. P. StevensonB. U. GadreSebastien BiscansSebastien BiscansLeo SingerRyan MageeJ. W. W. PrattA. GennaiRahul KumarHarald P. PfeifferHarald P. PfeifferA. CironeHyun LeeJ. Calderón BustilloM. RizzoV. PredoiI. W. MartinC. MessengerN. LeroyB. BécsyB. KhamesraM. KasprzackDavid CohenDavid E. McclellandG. RutinsGraham WoanE. SchreiberE. SchreiberP. KumarMiftar GanijaD. HuetS. H. HuttnerAndrew MelatosM. LorenziniA. MasserotRobert L. ByerStuart ReidA. SamajdarB. R. HallS. J. KapadiaJ. M. Gonzalez CastroMark HannamF. ThiesF. ThiesB. D. CheeseboroG. CerretaniC. R. BillmanTanja HindererA. StrunkHéctor EstellésN. LetendreM. F. CarneyP. J. EasterJ. M. IsacC. AulbertR. CavalieriD. RosińskaD. RosińskaPatrice HelloJacob ScheuerG. PaganoJ. P. ZendriT. HardwickD. SteinmeyerD. SteinmeyerT. Huynh-dinhChunglee KimBernard F. SchutzBernard F. SchutzLi JuP. T.h. PangT. EtzelJohn WordenP. CouvaresJonathan NewportBala R. IyerA. K. SrivastavaA. E. PaceA. Fernandez-galianaS. AppertA. GiazottoP. ShawhanI. FerranteH. CaoD. J. VineDaniel A. ShaddockBrittany KamaiY. BouffanaisC. V. KalaghatgiJ. HansonK. NapierGuido MuellerA. MillerL. TrozzoPriscilla CanizaresNicolas Sanchis-gualMichael E ZuckerMichael E ZuckerW. H. WangE. G. ThomasA. BastiP. CharltonKejia LeeS. MccormickRyan N. LangLloyd Paul AielloG. WangL. MatoneAlbert LazzariniM. BenschM. BenschF. TravassoA. EfflerKevin BarkettB. C. PantMarc FavataRoger JonesV. J. RomaA. P. SpencerD. D. BrownHang YuJan HarmsA. S. SenguptaHaocun YuSourav GhoshJ.-p. CoulonI. DorringtonImre BartosE. A. ChaseZ. FreiA. J. K. ChuaC. KrämerR. L. SavageA. S. BellM. LaxenCharalampos MarkakisAnthony A. AmatoN. Van BakelYongjung KimM. H. WimmerM. H. WimmerSatyanarayan Ray Pitambar MohapatraA. PerrecaG. GemmeM. DragoV. SequinoSamuele CorteseSamaya NissankeS. CarideM. BawajJ.-d. FournierM. YvertZifan ZhouI. A. BilenkoT. TheegT. TheegI. Di PalmaB. LantzTania RegimbauTania RegimbauGuenakh MitselmakherCollin D. CapanoB. A. BoomA. M. SergeevPhilip F. HopkinsV. DoliqueDenis MartynovMarco BazzanBritton D. SmithA. C. GreenM. BoerV. QuetschkeW. ParkerS. B. AndersonB. D. LackeyF. BrighentiPiotr JaranowskiJ. D. E. CreightonFausto AcerneseKipp CannonM. SteinkeM. SteinkeMartin M. FejerG. VedovatoJ. R. SmithR. BorkS. GhongeAniello GradoI. FioriDavid J. OttawayA. PaoliD. UgoliniP. ClearwaterAshutosh Kumar SinghAshutosh Kumar SinghM. HulkoSerena VinciguerraR. PedurandR. PedurandBenno WillkeBenno WillkeK. KawabeD. BuskulicS. M. AstonP. BookerP. BookerM. B. ShanerS. B. CoughlinS. B. CoughlinC. FeeBinlei DingA. GuptaC. IngramK. AultonealArchisman GhoshR. M. S. SchofieldK. UenoMichael W. CoughlinI. KhanDebnandini MukherjeeC. D. BoothW. KatzmanC. CahillaneJ. HennigS. DoravariS. DoravariJ. BirchS. BaeE. CocciaL. Van Der SchaafS. A. PaiC. GraefB. A. WeaverCody MessickJ. G. RollinsL.-w. WeiL.-w. WeiJessica SteinlechnerJessica SteinlechnerA. NeunzertT. ChmielF. Y. KhaliliBenjamin J. OwenA. PostS. MeshkovSeog OhJ. F. J. Van Den BrandA. F. BrooksM. HeursM. HeursK. G. ArunD. M. WilkenD. M. WilkenInnocenzo M. PintoI. BelahceneM. Fitz-axenF. SalemiP. BaconDaniel E. HolzS. T. CountrymanM. FaysM. LeonardiM. LeonardiFederico FerriniLijing ShaoG. VajenteS. M. GaebelS. SunilM. TaccaSascha HusaAndrew MatasL. E. WadeMartin HendryCecilio García-quirósM. C. DíazSurabhi SachdevChristopher J. MooreK. V. TokmakovG. VenugopalanV. GayathriS. WalshS. WalshMiriam CaberoAlessandra BuonannoAlessandra BuonannoD.b. DebraAntonios KontosKris RyanE. A. QuinteroR. KirchhoffR. KirchhoffJunwei CaoR. MetzdorffGabrielle AllenB. L. PearlstoneSamuel DelégliseMi ZhangS. MastrogiovanniR. K. LanzaChristian PedersenL. PinardC. GrayG. H. OginT. J. ShafferReed EssickD. S. RabelingS. KandhasamyB. SorazuM. MantovaniE. J. Fauchon-jonesM. LormandV. FafoneRana X. AdhikariB. PatricelliJ. MciverA. BoheD. S. WuD. S. WuMargaret MillhouseG. ValdesP. PuppoA. W. MuirAntoni Ramos-buadesV. V. FrolovA. SinghalLee MccullerN. MazumderY. BoetzelA. KutyniaT. T. NguyenAlena AnanyevaBenoit SassolasKen K. Y. NgA. HreibiC. PankowP. DupejA. Di LietoNevin N. WeinbergP. M. MeyersKendall AckleyR. K. NayakK. W. ChungX. GuoS. J. ChamberlinM. VasúthK. SiellezD. J. StopsS. G. GaonkarZachariah B. EtienneHaixing MiaoH. Y. ChiaB. GateleyHoward PanAaron BuikemaF. Magaña-sandovalT. D. AbbottJennifer WatchiM. BejgerF. MarionJonathan CripeZoheyr DoctorH. OhtaAndrea ChincariniB. MachenschalkFelix WellmannFelix WellmannF. DonovanWilliam YamL. WallaceA. KrólakR. FreyS. AscenziDuncan MeacherJ. DerbyK. A. ThorneW. Z. KorthS. C. TaitBarry C. BarishAlessandro BertoliniJ. WarnerR. PassaquietiJ. J. BeroO. BockK. L. DooleyK. L. DooleyAaron ZimmermanAaron ZimmermanPaul J. GrootM. ZevinTorrey CullenIsabel Cordero-carriónFrancesco PannaraleFangchen FengLisa BarsottiE. A. HuertaC. WhittleR. GoetzTarun SouradeepStanislav BabakStanislav BabakC. C. WipfE. J. KingS. KoleyM. BrinkmannM. BrinkmannM. Di GiovanniM. ConstancioK. E. GushwaSoichiro MorisakiJohn VeitchRoy WilliamsC. F. Da Silva CostaMairi SakellariadouM. WasJ. LehmannJ. LehmannEdward K. PorterM. J. CowartP. J. VeitchT. Z. SummerscalesS. GaudioAnirban DasguptaJong H. ChowJ. LiuA. PasqualettiD. M. MacleodR. KennedyD. PascucciE. A. MuñizS. BrunettA. DmitrievC. BradaschiaR. J. G. JonkerC. BeerV. BossilkovF. J. HernandezA. CummingP. FuldaA. RocchiV. GermainMoritz MehmetMoritz MehmetK. BossieMichael L. GorodetskyRyan LynchB. ShapiroDavid JonesG. PillantGeoffrey LovelaceP. G. MurrayA. BishtA. BishtR. C. WaletB. K. BergerV. P. MitrofanovMarco CavagliaF. Di RenzoE. GeninN. ArnaudMaggie TseFabien KéfélianC. RajanM. M. HankeM. M. HankeB. L. SwinkelsJ. ZhangF. BaldacciniL. F. OrtegaSylvia J. ZhuSylvia J. ZhuC. L. RomelH. M. LeeJ. H. HoughP. W. F. ForsythS. MitraOtto A. HannukselaH. VoccaEugeniy E. MikhailovM. J. HartS. E. BarclayJ. L. WillisJ. L. WillisM. EisenmannOfek BirnholtzC. De RossiW. Del PozzoP. F. CohadonH. HeitmannF. GarufiSurendra Nadh SomalaHongyu ShenSumanta TewariC. CocchieriB. GoncharovR. BirneyLionel LondonMilan GuptaD. C. CoyneG. MendellJ. TrinasticM. Kinley-hanlonVijay VarmaM. MacinnisP. RapagnaniSebastiano BernuzziSebastiano BernuzziO. HalimK. IzumiV. LorietteRebecca FisherK. S. PhukonJ. LiJ. EichholzS. KatsanevasJ. SureshD. B. TannerMadeline WadeP. LeaciA. CollaD. NoltingM. KorobkoP. T. BakerL. NaticchioniSalvatore VitaleA. L. UrbanO. De VaronaO. De VaronaD. Mendoza-gandaraD. Mendoza-gandaraK. W. TsangJ. R. PalamosColm TalbotAndreas FreiseVincenzo PierroPaul D. LaskyMatthew PitkinR. K.l. LoM. GranataMinchuan ZhouJ. K. BlackburnE. Chassande-mottinSheila RowanM. PürrerS. KwangTodd AdamsMichele ZanolinI. Magaña HernandezA. W. HeptonstallPablo Cerdá-duránVivien RaymondPeter R. SaulsonZ. TornasiTerry G. McraeL. G. ProkhorovA. A. ShahA. L. StuverVuk MandicTenglin LiI. KowalskaD. EstevezX. LiuEric HowellS. LeaveyS. LeaveyHai-ping ChengM. KatolikA. IessL. K. NuttallJon M. MillerR. MacasG. BillingsleyS. MacfoyM. RakhmanovG. M. HarryK. VenkateswaraR. CotestaYuri LevinRobert StoneAlessandro NagarA. R. WilliamsonA. R. WilliamsonS. D'antonioT. P. DownesB. B. MillerTyson LittenbergXing-jiang ZhuM. HaneyT. A. CallisterN. KijbunchooV. TiwariM. FyffeGabriela GonzalezK. R. CorleyA. AinB. PangMarie-anne BizouardA. K. LenonF. FrasconiE. Mejuto-villaR. De PietriR. De PietriJ. B. KannerRocco RomanoJohn D. ScottR. A. MercerS. OssokineJinsook KimT. J. MassingerG. A. ProdiT. VoV. KalogeraR. DesalvoM. A. OkadaO. V. PalashovSean T. McwilliamsF. PiergiovanniR. FlaminioM. PedrazaShubhanshu TiwariS. BarnumLeopoldo MilanoBadri KrishnanD. TuyenbayevMaria Ilaria Del PrincipeP. A. AltinJ. A. GiaimeH. FongG. GrecoM. AgathosD. BarkerD. FiorucciJ. JunkerJ. JunkerR. A. EisensteinB. J. J. SlagmolenHee-suk ChoHsiao-wen ChenMaher YazbackG. D. MeadorsH. FehrmannT. PrestegardA. PeleA. R. WadeNergis MavalvalaJerome DegallaixJ. S. KisselC. M. Mow-lowryW. RenBenjamin William AllenBenjamin William AllenBenjamin William AllenP. B. CovasFelice SorrentinoA. SawadskyG. D. HammondM. ChanJaved RanaMaria Alessandra PapaMaria Alessandra PapaMaria Alessandra PapaF. CavalierM. C. EdwardsMandar PatilAbhirup GhoshKarsten DanzmannKarsten DanzmannT. SadeckiT. Dal CantonMartin ObergaulingerSergey P. VyatchaninS. GrunewaldA. ChiummoD. MoraruC. CasentiniT. ZelenovaRiccardo BassiriMagnus ManskeMagnus ManskeGianpietro CagnoliGianpietro CagnoliHua WangE. MarosM. GosselinR. GreenE. E. CowanV. KondrashovW. K. WongM. DavierM. J. YapHartmut GroteB. F. WhitingSlawomir GrasJ. Casanueva DiazS. W. S. NgM. NeryM. NerySaniya KhanG. LosurdoEttore MajoranaP. EhrensPaul M. RickerD. C. Vander-hydeLaura SampsonOdylio D. AguiarArunava MukherjeeArunava MukherjeeY. SetyawatiH. KhanTristan BriantJade PowellL. SunV. ManganoD. H. ShoemakerM. BitossiG. BergmannG. BergmannP. SchaleK. WetteP. WeßelsP. WeßelsJ. MingJ. MingGiuseppe IntiniY. MinenkovJohn J. OhTimothy EvansJames HealyP. BrockillC. PalombaS. PriviteraSung-po ChaoC. Van Den BroeckM. S. ShahriarRory SmithC. AdamsR. M. BlairD. SiggD. B. KozakD. StocksC. VorvickS. W. BallmerD. M. ShoemakerS. HochheimS. HochheimN. A. RobertsonN. A. RobertsonJ. C. BayleyJ. G. BartlettMichelle E. WalkerG. MorenoLuca GammaitoniG. D. O'deaBruno GiacomazzoL. SammutL. KuoH. YamamotoE. CapocasaJ. C. DriggersA. SchönbeckB. RajbhandariC. C. YanceyH. WittelH. WittelM. DeenadayalanDaniel WysockiMárton TápaiDavid Jonathan HofmanS. G. SchwalbeA. MarkowitzW. G. AndersonG. CellaS. L. DanilishinS. L. DanilishinGiacomo CianiGiacomo CianiM. PhelpsF. AubinR. G. OrmistonG. StrattaB. P. AbbottE. K. GustafsonA. AlloccaS. V. AngelovaF. VetranoH. K. GulatiDavid H. ReitzeDavid H. ReitzeG. DályaS. G. CrowderJ. BosveldS. VassR. CoyneFabrice MatichardFabrice MatichardB. DayJesper MunchChandra Kant MishraR. BhandareR. De RosaCarl-johan HasterM. C. TringaliS. AntierM. Dovale ÁLvarezS. KauferS. KauferL. RollandE. K. WesselNeil J. CornishE. CuocoM. C. ArayaM. K. M. BaderS. E. DwyerDavid KeitelS. J. CooperC. LazzaroPatricia SchmidtV. BrissonJ. PrasadLiam CunninghamI. NardecchiaN. IndikRainer WeissF. RicciA. BrilletO. ChaibiA. Lartaux-vollardDaniel JohnsonJonathan BlackmanCarlos CepedaRobert J. MccarthyF. CiprianoSuvadeep BoseSuvadeep BoseR. GouatyC. CollinsW. W. JohnsonZ. MárkaC. C. BuchananM. MerzouguiSteven BloemenJonathan R. GairL. M. PerriN. A. LockerbieS. FrascaKai StaatsP. PopolizioKoji AraiDavid BlairJordan CampC. HorstAlberto VecchioLinqing WenL. ContiE. J. SanchezJ. M. FishnerG. GiordanoK. TolandAchamveedu GopakumarChristopher P. L. BerryWill M. FarrA. D. SilvaAlejandro Torres-fornéM. De LaurentisSanjay KumarMatthew EvansStephen FairhurstCarl BlairArchana PaiM. MontaniT. D. CreightonNancy AggarwalZahoor Ali KhanR. IntaJohn A. ClarkBen FarrW. S. KimFabrizio BaroneM. MohanChristophe ColletteC. J. PerezN. ManK. HaughianF. PaolettiP. RuggiB. D. O'brienA. MullaveyT. J. N. NelsonI. DaveE. CesariniJosé A. FontMaya FishbachMarek SzczepanczykM. FletcherB. HugheyC-h. LeeD. SchuetteD. SchuetteXiaohui FanRichard O'shaughnessyB. BarrS. E. GossanJ. A. TaylorB. SteltnerB. SteltnerLeo TsukadaIk Siong HengA. RüdigerA. RüdigerC. NorthThomas DentP. CorbanVladimir DergachevE. Z. HamiltonA. K. ZadrożnyJames WhelanP. AjithJ. PageV. BoschiS. MárkaJ. C. BarayogaRichard J. AbbottM. Van BeuzekomJ. NeilsonH. J. BultenL. GloverKenneth A. StrainJimin GeorgeM. SieniawskaM. C. Milovich-goffS. BiscoveanuJ. L. WrightAlessandra CorsiD. TalukderDavid A. WilliamsO. J. PiccinniP. J. SuttonAlyssa GarciaA. L. MillerK. S. KarvinenK. S. KarvinenAlex B. NielsenGregory AshtonJ. H. RomieG. KuehnG. KuehnFabio MarchesoniN. MukundL. R. CominskyR. GustafsonC. AffeldtC. AffeldtZhihui DuA. ParidaS. S. EikenberryP. AstoneLarne PekowskyKyungmin KimR. TaylorE. J. DawMaurizio CanepaM. PunturoP. H. NguyenS. RajaAntonio MarquinaS. E. StriginPaolo AddessoK. D. GiardinaI. W. HarryC. DreissigackerC. DreissigackerJ. K. WoffordM. A. PageC. BuyJ. ZweizigDebarati ChatterjeeT. DenkerT. DenkerRosa PoggianiB. O'reillyP. GruningV. FreyE. L. MerilhOlivier MinazzoliE. BonillaSebastian SteinlechnerJ. S. LangeS. FarinonP. RaffaiM. RazzanoA. NitzNikhil SarinPeter AufmuthN. BodeN. BodeJ. HanksDániel BartaD. LumacaChunnong ZhaoTravis RobsonS. A. BilgiliT. Di GirolamoJing WangNicholas DemosJ. D. LoughJ. D. LoughSoma MukherjeeK. MasonKazuhiro AgatsumaLászló Á. GergelyF. MartelliFrank OhmeM. TonelliKaran JaniE. C. FerreiraSanjeev DhurandharDaichi TsunaXin ChenR. M. MartinL. ReiHuang-wei PanGijs NelemansS. KarkiD. VerkindtV. KringelV. KringelE. A. HoustonE. D. HallJ. WesterweckK. MogushiDavid A. NicholsR. TsoPatrick M. KochPatrick M. KochP. J. KingK. HoltS. BanagiriTomasz BulikK. H. LaiAaron VietsV. SandbergJ. FeichtO. PunckenO. PunckenXavier SiemensJoey Shapiro KeyJ. R. SandersS. S. ForsythAlessandro LongoRichard J. OramFrançois BonduF. BadaraccoM. MuratoreHeinz-bernd EggensteinHeinz-bernd EggensteinA. ViceréRiccardo CiolfiYi ChenAthol J. KemballB. W. SchulteB. W. SchulteH. F. HamiltonM. C. HeintzeF. CarbognaniAndrew LundgrenS. XiaoW. S. KimA. A. CiobanuE. KatsavounidisJ. BetzwieserXiuling LiAntoine HeidmannH. RadkinsD. TöyräH. OvermierA. BozziN. A. HollandD. SellersJ. MeidamDavid CowardSheon ChuaRiccardo SturaniJ.-y. VinetR. BonnandD. HoakD. SentenacPatrick BradyE. GoetzS. PennG. L. MansellV. DattiloEdwin J. SonM. SaleemStefan HildY. MaM. VardaroF. RobinetA. Avila-alvarezK. GillWalter WinklerWalter WinklerA. S. MarkosyanHarald LückHarald LückL. NevinM. ChoG. GaurS. C. McguireJ. F. ReadS. Di PaceI. MaksimovicR. L. WardG. HemmingS. M. KoehlenbeckS. M. KoehlenbeckQ. ChuT. ZhangH. QiL. Magaña ZertucheLili YangThibaut JacqminM. BranchesiJ. C. BatchC. I. TorrieE. MasseraL. PossentiS. KlimenkoEdward SeidelM. AstO. E. S. SauterM. OliverDouglas DavisGeraint PrattenH. FairJ. WoehlerJ. WoehlerAndrea TaracchiniD. BersanettiB. AgarwalJ. V. Van HeijningenYu WangD. PassuelloS. ChungG. BogaertEric ThraneC. MichelSarah CaudillT. D. KnowlesR. Quitzow-jamesV. B. AdyaV. B. AdyaF. ClevaM. P. RossT. B. EdoM. PichotMaximiliano IsiLionel MartelliniE. M. GretarssonD. BeniwalPeter FritschelM. Masso-reidYu ZhangYu ZhangL. E. SanchezEnrico CalloniG. TraylorThomas CorbittL. SalconiC. A. CostaD. V. AtallahLaura CadonatiL. KleybolteDaniel R. GeorgeSusan M. ScottC. E. CirelliChad HannaA. BramleyJ. OberlingM. PirelloN. V. KeerthanaA. J. WeinsteinF. NoceraAlicia M. SintesJay D. TassonM. LandryL. Di FioreB. MoursC. AustinM. BarsugliaK. ChatziioannouHyang Woon LeeA. GrantL. ZhangS. A. UsmanRoman SchnabelJ. E. BrauA. A. Van VeggelEfim A. KhazanovG. BallardinD. J. McmanusS. D. LinkerR. RobieMark A. ScheelF. ClaraM. A. AloyJ. S. AreedaP. ThomasM. ArèneL. MereniM. ThomasH. VahlbruchH. VahlbruchJ. C. MillsK. RilesH. MiddletonM. WeinertM. WeinertH. A. G. GabbardF. FidecaroG. M. GuidiH. N. IsaG. KangA. Pal-singh

subject

Physics010308 nuclear & particles physicsGravitational waveGeneral Physics and AstronomyBreaking wave7. Clean energy01 natural sciencesInstabilityComputational physicsNeutron starStarsAmplitude13. Climate action0103 physical sciencesWaveformExtreme value theory010303 astronomy & astrophysics

description

We analyze the impact of a proposed tidal instability coupling p modes and g modes within neutron stars on GW170817. This nonresonant instability transfers energy from the orbit of the binary to internal modes of the stars, accelerating the gravitational-wave driven inspiral. We model the impact of this instability on the phasing of the gravitational wave signal using three parameters per star: An overall amplitude, a saturation frequency, and a spectral index. Incorporating these additional parameters, we compute the Bayes factor (lnB!pgpg) comparing our p-g model to a standard one. We find that the observed signal is consistent with waveform models that neglect p-g effects, with lnB!pgpg=0.03-0.58+0.70 (maximum a posteriori and 90% credible region). By injecting simulated signals that do not include p-g effects and recovering them with the p-g model, we show that there is a ≃50% probability of obtaining similar lnB!pgpg even when p-g effects are absent. We find that the p-g amplitude for 1.4 MâSneutron stars is constrained to less than a few tenths of the theoretical maximum, with maxima a posteriori near one-Tenth this maximum and p-g saturation frequency ∼70 Hz. This suggests that there are less than a few hundred excited modes, assuming they all saturate by wave breaking. For comparison, theoretical upper bounds suggest a103 modes saturate by wave breaking. Thus, the measured constraints only rule out extreme values of the p-g parameters. They also imply that the instability dissipates a1051 erg over the entire inspiral, i.e., less than a few percent of the energy radiated as gravitational waves.

https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.122.061104